Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

I watched all the episodes. Firstly, I am glad that the participants from Pakistan are OUTSTANDING! I am so happy for them.

Himesh and Atif are being childish. A cold war is there for I see, NO REASON. Abida Parveen is completely Allah wali.. so she is mostly not commenting which is quite disturbing. What I felt was, when Indian singers are performing, Asha ji is describing that how wonderful was that performance, like, kiya zabardast performance thi, dil ko chuu gaye, seenay main ja ke lagi, tumhari awaz aisee hay jese moti girr rahay hain, kia khoobsoorti hay, blah blah, but when a Paki singer is giving a mindblowing performance, she says AB kiya bolun, ye lo 10 marks, tareef hi nahin ho pa rahi unse, lafz hi nahin mil rahay unko, which is quite unfair. The words of a legend helps a lot and gives you confidence, which Asha ji lacks when it comes to appreciate Pakistani Participants. Still ye 0 and 10 ka rule india ko khud bhaari parr raha hay, maybe they thought Pakis lack in SURR TAAL which has been proved wrong by our singers and they are playing safe, now they dont need to care about the Alap and that stuff, even if they sing a simple song, they should be on surr thats it and thats for what the marks are given!! LOL!

Personally I believe its jut not surr but the entire performance, the outstanding performances that can give you goosebumps, a performance where a person feel like dancing, an energy, enthusiasm, power is what an entire performance is, but since Asha Ji gave an indian singer 10 where he did lack of JOSH (and the theme was JOSH too), she is now bound to ignore everything but surr!! I am glad our Paki Singers are ON surrs!!

Allah Bless Pakistan.

Award kisi ka bhi ho, talent lafzo aur awards ka mohtaj nahin. Talent nazar ata hay aur jo hamen nazar aagya hamaray Paki singers main!!
I wish them BEST of luck!! Love to all of them :k:

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

Sara Raza :wub:

I love her

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

Sara Raza. :wub:

I love her too.

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

its odd seeing himesh act like hes the best singer. he hasnt go a day job-hence the stupid judge role on a silly show. if he was in demand with all the bollywood flicks, he wouldnt be seeen dead doing this.

anyway, himesh and atif- not great singers,so the whole show is ridiculous. if the judges were sonu nigam and rahat ali khan- that would be justified.

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

i think they are told to act like this because otherwise show wont atract any viewvership...

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

I like both Atif and Himesh as singers. Their songs are fun to listen to.

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

nasal singers

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

I don't know what the background of other singers is, but Sara Raza has won in another singing show in India before and since then has been quite active in Pakistan as a singer.

I wonder if she has an unfair advantage over others.

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

That's a style too. Isn't it ?

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

Atif- the most dardful voice which I love... his songs simply makes me cry and thats what a singer's quality!!
Himesh- I love his composition, he is one of the great composers, Love TERE NAAM simply!!

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

Classical Ustads didn't like that practice. Naak saans lene ke liye hain bolne ya gaane ke liye nahin. Did you notice that they both speak normally (without being nasal) then why they sing with nose?

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

Guys lemme tell you the truth, when the audition was going on, Feb 17 and 18 I guess that was! I was suffering from Fever and flu and thats y couldn’t go :frowning: otherwise I had to :frowning: and after a couple of days, when I contacted the management of the show through my PR, they said the team has already been finalized and ready to leave for Dubai :frowning:
:teary2:
I am glad Sara is there, I see myself and my spirit in her :slight_smile: except of sometimes she start singing from throat but she never been off the notes so thats awesome and I am glad the whole team is great!! :k:

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

I watched only one episode of it. I like Sara's voice . My older sis loves sara as she is a smiley and bubbly girl lol

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

:hoonh:

Copy cat

She is already in the finals :wub:

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

Darn. We could have been famous.

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

Most of the current Pakistani singers are like that.

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

LOL :hehe: itna zaroor yaqeen hota ke pooray GS se to votes mil hi janay hain :smiley:

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

I am not a big Himesh fan, but to be fair even when Himesh was doing 25-30 movies in a year he was a judge on Sa Re Ga Ma Pa along with many other Bollywood music directors.

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

Sara Raza participated in Sa Re Ga Ma Pa a few years ago, but did not win. She did gain a lot of popularity on both sides of the border though. Personally, I did not like her back then, but looks like she has really worked on her singing in the past few years and is a much better singer now.

Re: Sur Kshetra - India/Pakistan musical fight

This week, Runa Laila started singing Dama Dam Must Qalandar extempore, to show a participant, and Abida and Asha joined in with alaaps.

It was an exhilarating, feel-good performance. Very unexpected, exciting and high-energy. Atif also joined in at the end for a bit even though his voice was a little shaky.