Sunni Perspective on Shia Traditions

[badabing]

Re: Sunni Perspective on Shia Traditions

@PyariCgudia

I think another good question is “Did Ali (R) tell people that he was a divine Imam?” - is there evidence for him saying such a thing? You’d think if he was given this position, he would have spoken up?

Sweetheart, you keep going back to “where is it explicitly stated there are 12 imams with devine right etc” - but what you are either not grasping or choosing not to is that you start from a position of bias by basing your opinions solely on sunni literature which is pro banu ummaya yet “zuban pur tala laga huwa” when it comes to banu hashim. I was like you once (raised hanafi from 5-16) , until I started to read everythng and anything and base my beliefs upon the “Kirdaar” of the individual narrating a hadith or making a judgement (and yes, this required further reading!) rather then simply that it is shaih because imams muslim and bukhari had done the edited work already.