Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

The Quran clearly forbids suicide under any circumstance yet the Mullahs and Militants urge the youth to carry them out falsly promising them that God has promised them paradise and virgins. Where are we going wrong? We the muslim people have allowed these hijackers of the faith to become false preachers. If a lie is told many times it becomes the accepted truth, like it has now. These so called defenders of Islam are the REAL enemies of Islam. The majority of the Muslims of the world are being to ransom by these evil elements. Like a virus in the body, it has to be dealt with, like wise majority Muslims should not allow these viral entities to spread and become a cancer!

SUICIDE BOMBING

Islam (Submission) condemns suicide as much as it condemns oppression and aggression against others. While the Muslims (Submitters) are commanded to stand for their rights and defend themselves, their properties and their freedom they are told to first resort to peace advocate tolerance and disregard the ignorant. The following verses from the Quran show how the Quran describes suicide, such an important issue in our life that was made the center of the conflict in the Middle East lately.

[2:195] You shall spend in the cause of GOD; do not throw yourselves with your own hands into destruction. You shall be charitable; GOD loves the charitable.

4:29] O you who believe, do not consume each others’ properties illicitly - only mutually acceptable transactions are permitted. You shall not kill yourselves. GOD is Merciful towards you.

4:30] Anyone who commits these transgressions, maliciously and deliberately, we will condemn him to Hell. This is easy for GOD to do.

Suicide bombing by young uninformed Muslim youths has been carried out almost routinely as a mean of revenge in the Middle East conflict. It is mainly done to avenge their oppression, occupation and loss of freedom they have been experiencing all their life. It is carried out by the youth who lost all the hope to a peaceful settlement as they witnessed their families, loved ones, neighbors, and the innocent bystanders die or tortured at the hand of a merciless occupying force. Despite these intolerable situation no permission can be found in Islam to avenge by suicide bombing or by targeting the innocent civilians. These young desperate Muslim youth have been taught what is NOT in the Quran, and what was never promised by God in the Holy book.

As the verses quoted above show, suicide in any form is condemned by God, no excuse given under any circumstances. The Quran does not promise Heaven (Paradise) to those who commit suicide but rather warn of condemnation to Hell. The promise of paradise or of virgin wives in Heaven for those suicide bombers and those who kill the innocent civilians has no basis in Islam and cannot be found anywhere in the Quran. These fabrications taught to these poor desperate Muslim youths originated probably from the man made books of Hadiths and Sunna that were condemned by God and by the prophet Muhammad himself who told his followers to follow ONLY the Quran.

Suicide is a state of disbelief and loss of faith that is condemned by God throughout the Quran. In the Quran, God commands the believers never to despair or lose hope and instead work for a brighter future.

[12:87] “… None despairs of GOD’s grace except the disbelieving people.”

We do understand the dire situation in which these youth live and we do have the full sympathy to their suffering and oppression , but we cannot agree with breaking God’s commandment. Oppression is not a reason to break God’s law, on the contrary oppression is a good reason to hold tight to these commandments and to show the world the true and peaceful face of Islam (Submission). If we break God’s law we move ourselves away from His mercy and lose His support. We should know that it is by following God’s law in the Quran we will gain dignity and sovereignty on our land while achieving peace, tolerance and love to the whole world around us. We have to believe that two wrongs will not make one right. Now after thousands of wrongs carried out by both sides in the conflict, no right emerged and will never emerge. Unless we go back to God’s commandments in the scriptures, the Torah, Gospel and/or the Quran, there will be no success and no victory for any group. . All the scriptures call on the people to live in peace and harmony and to advocate tolerance. Victory as far as God is concerned is achieved by the guarantee of freedom and justice for all and not by the domination of one group or nation above another..

Quran urges the followers of Islam (Submission) to resort to peace first and whenever possible but they may fight the oppressors if peaceful means failed. Fighting does not include killing the innocent civilians and the least expecting people as this reflects the meanest kind of character and does not reflect the spirit and/or teachings of Islam (Submission.) These suicide bombers can contribute more and better for the society if they direct their efforts into teaching the world about their cause and work with their neighbors to strengthen their stand against oppression, or be a part of the peaceful solution of the problem they have been facing instead of being a reason for its failure.

The blame can be equally thrown at the oppressors who gave these youths no chance or HOPE to live in dignity and freedom. The world has to speak up against the oppression and occupation of the land and life of these people as well. No where in any divine or human law is a place for a group of people to live at the expense of oppressing others or occupying their homes, land, and life. Peace can only be achieved when mutual respect of human life and properties are achieved.

We should make every effort to educate our young and youth of the Quranic commandments and it is as important for the free world to make every effort to stop this aggression and oppression against a whole nation under occupation that find no exit from this desperate situation except by death or dying.

(8:61) “If they resort to peace, so shall you, and put your trust in GOD. He is the Hearer, the Omniscient.”

(7:199) You shall resort to pardon, advocate tolerance, and disregard the ignorant.

(16:90) GOD advocates justice, charity, and regarding the relatives. And He forbids evil, vice, and transgression. He enlightens you, that you may take heed.

(49:13) O people, we created you from the same male and female, and rendered you distinct peoples and tribes, that you may recognize one another. The best among you in the sight of GOD is the most righteous. GOD is Omniscient, Cognizant.

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

Suicide Bombing (according to some scholars) is allowed but that is only when you are in battle field, face to face with enemies, or you know that certain group of enemies is going to kill you if you dont kill them first (even if you are not in battle field).

Killing civillians by any way (suicide bombing, shooting, booby traps, road side bombs) is strictly prohibited in Islam. May Allah guide us better

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

Like the situations back in 1965 war between india and pakistan when india brought 600 tanks (second highest number after world war II) in the battlefield. Pak Army's jawan from Sialkot were the one who carried out suicide bombing against these tanks :)

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

Please Name those Scholars?

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

Ah, you got me there. I just heard that on a recording, and I present it as a statement from a scholar. Even he was not presenting it as a fatwa or anything. I do not rememebr the name and its OK to believe oterwise. I can tell you his name but dont remember when and where I heard that from him.

Though I cannot stand behind my statement but I think that because we use the term Suicide Bombing, we get stuck with the word Suicide. Japanese bombers did that in pearl harbor. They called it Kamikaze (means "wind from God" in japanese) and take pride on that.

In ghazawa's, when sahaba (individually) took their swords and rushed in enemies army, it was a suicidal act. And they got killed buut not without killing few enemies.

That is why I think that in War or war like situation, their might be a justification. Like in Iraq, entering an army camp. But not on streets of London. There is no justification of that what so ever

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

Maybe if people would actually strive to understand the Quran instead of tape recording it in their minds, maybe then theyll understand how Islam doesnt allow suiide bombing.

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

Did they strap explosives around their chests? Any sources?

Re: Suicide Bombing…WHY?

they strapped bombs around their waist.

Here](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/showpost.php?p=5156338&postcount=8) is the source

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

You seem to be taking it personaly. I just shared a view, not to start an arguement. I aplogize for not being a scholar on Quran, like you. What ever little I know, I got most of that from listening and not through Google search engine. When it comes to religion, I rather listen to a recording than to read a website.

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

I personally don't think jumping into a massive crowd of people, waving a sword is the same as blowing yourself up.

One has a high probability of death. The other one is absolutely certain.

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

Who gives these scholars the right to change what has all ready been ordained. Islam will become like the Christianity, where their scholars have legitamised wrongs into rights. We the people seem to go along with "So and so scholar or mufti has said it is ok". I haven't read anywhere that suicide bombing is allowed in war. I will try and find this allowance.

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

My point is that the term we use in a genralise way "suicide bombing/attack " automatically makes it look bad. I am not a supporter of suicide bombing. I think that it is one of the biggest crime against humanity.

In war when your only options are kill or to get killed, that could've been a tactic, provided that you dont strap a young kid or inncocent civilian and send him to the front line inside enemeies camp.

Do I sound like a supporter of Suicide attacks? I aplogize if I do. Am I a supporter? Heck no

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

I think people do not understand what suicide means. Its when you take your life out of hopelessness and that is what Islam forbids. Suicide is a matter of perspective and depends on what cause it serves.

Killing yourself to hurt others as two sides to the coin, is it while fighting an enemy or to further a political cause. In my opinion the one to further a political cause is what is wrong, which you see rampant especially in Palestine and Iraq. To take your life while fighting is not suicide or wrong either because you are likely to get killed if you are unable to defend yourself, when that becomes obvious to you you kill yourself ensuring that you still get your enemy with you and your death is not a waste.

This is a very touchy issue and it heavily if not solely dependent on the circumstances in which a person takes his life. As someone noted earlier in the 1965 Indo-Pak war, the soldiers did strap bombs to themselves to stop the Indain tank assult, thats why Major Raza Aziz Bhatti earned a Nishan e Haider. This was done in defense and during a war. The intentions of the other side were well known and clear.

However people performing suicide bombings because they want to get the world attention is very shady and most probably wrong especially when they blow up their own people. And don't forget these people are not acting with command of their state or country. There is a very thin line which makes it right or wrong. Anyone being sent on an assasination attempt is also really going towards suicide, should he fail or get caught, it is very likely he will get killed. Some may call it suicide or something else.

I judge by seeing who was the victim of it, what was the role of the victim and what is the cause that is being fought for and how it affects the cause? And in what environment was it carried out. There is more than one thing to consider.

2 Likes

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

I think you said it better than what I was trying to say. Good writing

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

Pak jawans also raped 20 thousand(according to Susan Brownmiller 40 thousand) Bangali women in 1971. So lets keep their examples aside.

Re: Suicide Bombing…WHY?

:salam: Behna

Kiya haal hain aap ke?

Now lets not also forget that Bengalis huddling their women forth to pry away the Paki army was not a morally good thing to do either however it still does note excuse Paki army for what they might have done. And these figures are exagerated. Past sins are history. And we were talking about 1965 war, 1971 comes after that. :slight_smile:

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

hareem, you are taking this whole thing in a different direction. Pak military is not a human body where you punish the whole body for the bad-doing of one part of it. Please dont embarrass yourself by pointing out the mistakes of some and blaming all for that.

Our problem is this that we are very ungrateful people. If one of those Jawans who strap themselves in 1965 were your uncle or grandfather, you would be posting their pictures on this website with words like shaheed and martyr, but because they were someone else’s father or brother, why should we care.

US army is killing innocents and raping girls at gun points in Iraq in front of their fathers and brothers (and killing all of them after that). I am sure that you have read these reports. But you should see how US people treat their soldiers after they come back from Iraq. Town mayors arrange a parade for them; local radio and TV stations do a special broadcast on them. Local newspaper calls them Heroes.

And what we do, pooh pooh our own soldiers who are getting few thousand rupees salaries, on duty for 24 hours, defend our boundaries, get killed while doing that an leave their kids and wives to us so we can ridicule them for the rest of their lives. Shame on us

Re: Suicide Bombing…WHY?

Wow! :k:

Re: Suicide Bombing…WHY?

Hmmm.. USR bhai, it looks like that after a tough start, we are friends now. Thanks

Re: Suicide Bombing.....WHY?

Our Prophet Muhammad (SAW) mentioned suicide many times, a few of these incidents are recorded in Muhammad Ibn Ismael's, 'Sahih Al-Bukhari'. In one incident the Prophet (SAW) said, "Whoever intentionally swears falsely by a religion other than Islam, then he is what he has said, (e.g. if he says, 'If such thing is not true then I am a Jew,' he is really a Jew if he is a liar). And whoever commits suicide with a piece of iron, he will be punished with the same piece of iron in the Hell-fire."
Narrated by Jundub: The Prophet (SAW) said, "A man was inflicted with wounds and he commited suicide, and so Allah said: My slave has caused death on himself hurriedly, so I forbid Paradise for him."
Narrated by Abu Hurairah (RA): The Prophet (SAW) said, "He who commits suicide by throttling shall keep on throttling himself in the Hell-fire (forever), and he who commits suicide by stabbing himself, he shall keep stabbing himself in the Hell-fire (forever)."
From the sayings of Allah and his Prophet (SAW), we can see suicide is not accepted in Islam and we can also see through other sources, it is also prohibited in other religions.