in my anthropology class today, some american girl said in her speech that in islam, women who are accused of adultry are stonned to death, which right and wrong. it is correct because this is the islamic punishment for adultrers BUT if you note, she didn’t mention men there. so after calss i talked to my teacher about it and clarified it that is FOR MEN AS WELL. so she told me why don’t you give a speech on monday to the whole class, which consists of more than a 100 students. i said ok but i am really nervouse because this is what i wanted to avoid, to speak before the whole class, but now i have to do this for sake of islam because people are already confused about islam A LOT. so pray that it goes well and i don’t get nervous.
Moving your thread to Religion forum as it is more relevent there.
Also, you might wanna look at the following threads: Stoning sentence for Pakistan woman and Stoning to death is not Islamic
Mods please move it to the Religion Section
and u religious Boys & Girls Please help my friend pakistani-darinda
for his address to the Nation ![]()
Thanks!
P.S.
Yar abhi sirf itni hi help kar sakta hon
Insha ALLAH every thing will be fine .. ALLAh will help you.. Aameen!
dun listen to munkireen-e-hadith and munkireen-e-sunnah here in gupshup though cause ironically u have posted this thread and will be busted for that i am sure.. but be firm:)
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by Gadha: *
Insha ALLAH every thing will be fine .. ALLAh will help you.. Aameen!
dun listen to munkireen-e-hadith and munkireen-e-sunnah here in gupshup though cause ironically u have posted this thread and will be busted for that i am sure.. but be firm:)
[/QUOTE]
Thanks Donk, Hey I see that you are very close to 10 grand, congrats in advance haan!!! :10 grand wala icon:
OK Paki Darinday, One thing I know for sure and that is the punishment, it is differs in different c-nay-rio e.g.
1) Married woman and single guy
2) Married guy and signle woman
3) Married folks but not husband and wife
and in rare cases
4) Age factor of the person in question
Franky, I wish I was there to see the eyes of the listeners. Best O'luck t'you.
no help
Well, if it’s in the Koran, it’s what it is since after all, it is the word of Allah. On a seperate note, stoning is such a medieval form of punishment if applied to today’s times. The gas chamber or firing squad seem the better options, no?! :kaboom: :soldier: ![]()
It doesn't say in the Quran that adultrers should be stoned to death.
The Quran mentions 100 lashes as the punihsment for illegal sexual intercourse. It doesn’t mention stoning.
The punihsment of stoning is invoked based on a several Hadiths, which most scholars agree carry a high degree of authenticity. It is recorded that the Khalifah and Amir-ul-Mumineen Umar Bin Al-Khattab (ra) was very concerned that given the absence of a directive to stone to death in the Quran, Muslims in later times would stop doing it despite its being done in the time of the Prophet (saws)
Pakbeast, the best evidence I can give you is the Hadith…
more info can be found here…
Guys, thanx for clarifrying for all of us :)
thanx for all the replies. i am searching on this topic as well and i have to finish my search before monday. now some websites say that it is right to stone them to death, whereas some mention the lashes. i am confused, which one is said in quran? i think i have to study surah noor's translation. that's where it's mentioned, right?
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by mAd_ScIeNtIsT: *
The Quran mentions 100 lashes as the punihsment for illegal sexual intercourse. It doesn't mention stoning.
u think a person willl survive after getting 100 lashes ?? forget stoning for nowww....i think 100 lashes would do the job!!
stoning to death is mentioned in the sahih hadith, as a man came upto the prophet(saw) and told him i have had illegal relations with a woman. the prophet was looking for excuses for him, so that he might not get the punishment of stoning to death. many hadiths state stoning of death for a married man or woman who have sex outside marriage. the lashing is for the man or woman who are single.
THATS SICK
What is sick uklawyer is adultery.
If death is the sentence, then why do it in such a horrific manner? There are many more reasonable ways to put someone to death. That practice should be abolished everywhere, as it's just too barbaric. As a human being, I can never participate or even watch this being done to another human being.
why people take such a risk to commit adutery? is it that hard
to be good voluntarily?
that's the punishment islam has set for adultery.......don't like it, too bad! either don't do it or change your religion
[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by pakbeast: *
that's the punishment islam has set for adultery.......don't like it, too bad! either don't do it or change your religion
[/QUOTE]
That punishment is pretty much irrelavent in todays society and in most countries. I'd like to see a muslim person being stoned to death for adultry anywhere in North America for instance. It would be the stoners who would be put to death for murder (in some cases) or jailed for life.