Status of Ali(ra) in Ahadees

aqeel123 · January 10, 2009, 7:42pm

i would have to agree with you but in the light of what Prof. Qadri said its not just an ordinary mistake if u go on a war against Imam Ali a.s, u r no more momin, hence munaiq !

aqm805 · January 10, 2009, 8:49pm

Meray bhai, it does not matter at all who is CONCLUDED as munafiq or kaafir or whatever in these discussions
If person A calls person B by any disrespectful noun or thinks about him/her like that, does it matter?
Jo falah paa gayay so paa gayay

Got my point of view?

Jussssssssst relax buddy!

desert_bird · January 10, 2009, 10:34pm

Re: Status of Ali(ra) in Ahadees

I ma tired of lenghty debates , so accepted it, happy :)

aqeel123 · January 10, 2009, 10:49pm

Re: Status of Ali(ra) in Ahadees

i am not challeneging someone for a debate ... my father is a big fan of Prof. Tahir ul qadri and wanted him to call him for a majlis however i dunt think that guy is not being honest to himself.... i wish i get to ask him some questions some time in life !

However this is just an opnion i have abt him.... it doesnt mean i have anything personal against anyone ! So relaaaaax ! :)

Das_Reich · January 13, 2009, 1:07am

Re: Status of Ali(ra) in Ahadees

^maybe he does not agree with the way u guys hold majalis ...have u thought of that ?

aqeel123 · January 13, 2009, 5:43pm

Re: Status of Ali(ra) in Ahadees

^ yaaar, i dunt know which fiqh are you ! but u r really bothered by shia's!, i have no clue y do u even come up with things like that ? anyway what he said was "he was busy writing a book on Iman-e- Abu talib otherwise he has no problem"... dunt beleive me try apporaching him urself and tell him u r a shia and u want him to come for a majlis !