split discussion regarding history - pakistan and india

[ssingh]

Re: split discussion regarding history - pakistan and india

@roadrunner

I suppose I have to spell it out for you. The Rig Veda was the books of the Vedic Aryans written around 1200 BC. This was written in Pakistan and what true Vedism was. The Artha Veda was written 800 years later in the Ganges, after the Vedic Aryans had brought the Rig Veda to the Ganges. Perhaps it was written by a Tamilian, but just because it has Veda at the end of it, does not mean the Rig Veda belongs to you.

The darker Gods that were created later were Shiva and Krishna, and some others

I knew u will tell this. Then how come the gods of rig veda and other vedas are same?.....Agni indra are mentioned in other vedas as well. This is true that Rig veda was composed around the regions of pakistan.atleast with the evidence which tells. it could be even iran or afghanistan.

Do you know that another name of shiva is rudra which is mentioned in rig veda?. krishna is not mentioned but his another name vishnu is mentioned in rig veda. If you are also referring to Ganapathi, it is also mentioned in rig veda called brahmanaspathi. How come?..

You know what, with all this discussion, u cannot tell anything with confidence. Aryans did come to subcontinent. They didn't bring rig veda, they just invaded. Basically both aryans and dravidians were both, followers of vedic religion. Only thing is one invaded the other. that's all i can conclude.