if you want to discuss these acts (whihc you are referring to barbaric actS) why don’t you try to refer to those “criminal” stats and compare them between the countries which are following 'em (lets say Arabia or IRAN) and which are not following 'em (lets say US). you will get clear numbers which will tell you the criminal rates of these countries.
if you are arguing on the fact that its barbaric then you gota listen to the other story as well. this way of punishment will actually give others a lesson of not doing this act (I am not talking whether this woman was culprit or not .. this all together another topic) .. how many of you actually get afraid of the “punishment” of killing someone? we just heard that the killer would be hanged by death .. but do we ever feel it threatening? unless we see something like that?
Its just like when a child do a mistake in a class so he got punished right infront of class so that other class know what they will get if they try to do pranks or don’t complete hteir homework. Why don’t you go and tell ALL THE SCHOOLS in the world that when a child does a mistake, take him to some other room and then give the punishment and bring him back? Does that make sense?
Your Comment about “why doesn’t Allah send messengers to clarfiy things after 1400 years” etc clearly tells your state of mind. you don’t even believe in Allah then why the hell are you arguing on some RELIGIOUS matter? does that make sense or you are just trying to tell rest of the people that I am illiterate enough to get my way out of ISLAM and its BELIEVES and you should too ??
@ Someone who tried to relate islam and science. Let me make few things clear which most of the people do when relating islam with science
- Keep these things apart from each other
- If you really want to relate these things that make sure you have the depth of science and the depth of islam to understand things. you can get the depth of science but getting depth of islam, you can’t get it ..
.. .. - Our brain has been limited to the imaginations and knowledge which is bounded by this “world” boundary. We can’t understand things beyond our imaginations. how come you ever understand things in detail of islam?? though the easy things are well enough proved by science, but understanding the depth - difficult.