Some questions

Do I need a disclaimer first? I am a muslim, alhamdulilah. I am an ordinary person and do what ordinary people do - and I am definitely less informed than a lot of you people who have good understanding of religion. There are certain questions that bother me at times, I don’t know if I am not supposed to think about this stuff, but perhaps this is our nature as humanoids. I do believe in Allah, the supreme power, whose existence is evident scientifically and spiritually.

Compared to the universe, or even our planet, my existence is nothing. In the wide array of things, I am just a negligible and insignificant biological being. Why was I created in the first place? Are all my actions, my birth, my death, my fate, my reward and punishment - all pre-decided? What am I doing running around then? Where does my free will fit in? Religiously, I am a negligent and defiant person. I am not at all regular at namaz. So am I in for an infinite period of torture and punishment? If I die today, I don’t see many compelling reasons for my forgiveness. Alright, first question would be namaz? So they would be dragging my defiant butt straight to the pits of hell right after the first question. For some laziness and some defiance due to stupid reasons (unfortunate events, pessimistic feeling, just being upset), I would be punished for enernity? Now why would Allah want to do that and how is that fair? Honestly when I hear people talk about the azaab in grave and hereafter, it scares the heck out of me. Like how many more minutes, hours, days, months or years do I have here - struggling to survive - before I am taken away for an eternal chitter parade?

Further, things which perhaps I shouldn’t be thinking about are - why did Allah create insignificant beings like us in the first place? Does he just sit there and keep watching us do our thing? and later he will have the judgement day and then watch us burn in hell or enjoy in heaven? He created all the souls, he created good and evil, so if someone is evil, how is that his fault? What would he be punished for - if it was his fate to do evil and this is what he was made for? How do you informed and educated people satisfy atheists of these questions?

I know some of these questions are plain stupid. If any of you people, who are much more sensible and learned mashallah, can give me any clear answers, I would really appreciate it. If not, I would understand.

Please, do not confuse me further with any complex mumba jumba or links. Thank you.

Re: Some questions

What u need is a -- Murshid.

Re: Some questions

^He said "don't confuse me". :)

Re: Some questions

^^

Thats why i kept it simple :)

Thats exactly what I used to think before I turned Agnostic.

Re: Some questions

I was listening to this lecture while driving to my work this morning.
I do not agree with his treatment of other religions and his comments about why atom bomb was created and why Americans consume more.
But what he says about the way Islam answer the question “why we are here?” is brilliant .

Purpose of Creation

Re: Some questions

Sarge - lol ok.

Mirch bhai - thank you. I'll listen to it hopefully sometime soon.

Come on people, anyone?

Re: Some questions

^I don't want to confuse you further but my understanding is very simple. This life is a test and I believe that God is the most Just and he can see what's in our hearts so if someone is not regular in prayer but does have a sincere and loving heart then God is aware of that and He will do justice. Also, there are sayings of the Prophet(SAW) that God's mercy exceeds His wrath/anger.

Re: Some questions

because if it was his fate to do evil, Allah Swt has given humans free will. No one is inherently evil. They are not born that way.

Allah Swt did not create you to blind worship, for that he had his angels. You were created to question, as you rightly are right now!

Re: Some questions

From simple, I will start explaining a little more now.

Actually, a Murshid can save you from Questions of Munkir and Nakeer as well as torment of the grave. He will also make sure that you reach Aalim-e-Barzakh and stay there till the judgement day. He will then be with you on the Day of Judgement and you will stand under his umbrella till you are called by ALLAH for questioning.Then again, if You have kept your Murshid happy(You keep Murshid happy by doing what He tells you to do, and what He tells you to do is always what ALLAH/religion tells you to do) during lifetime, then ALLAH may let you go again coz of ur Murshid.

In your life time, the Murshid will again play a part and make dua for you everynight and will make sure you never get in a problem.He is responsible that you never sleep empty stomach or never get jobless etc and that you always get what you desire. In return you have to serve him,which is by abiding what Islam says and for example,if u find praying namaz difficult,he will ask ALLAH to create circumstances for you to pray namaz easily

Re: Some questions

I think I can answer your questions. But I let mirch do the job.
More ppl taking, point gets lost quickly. :)

I think asking questions is a good thing. Allah asks us all to seek knowledge. It is better to ask and probe rather that to follow religion blindly and as if it was a method.

I believe that Allah created us all for a reason. In the greater scheme of things we may seem irrelevant because there are billions of people also around us but I believe each and every one of has a reason, which we may not realise in this lifetime. I dont think you ahve to be a Mother Teresa or a Gandhi figure, but aslong as you are fair, just and honest in your lifetime and adhere to what is asked of you, then you do have a purpose. After all, we don't know which of our actions may please the Almighty the most.

Allah gave us free will. Ideally we should do right rather than wrong and for this Allah has given us guidelines and encourages us to do good to all and bad to none. Allah has decided our destiny yet there is also margin for one to exercise their free will. For example, if one has an exam coming up and does not revise/study and sits and wait for their destiny to decide their outcome and help them, then unfortunately it does not work that way. We are encouraged to help ourselves become better and I think that is where free will kicks in as well as our daily actions which all culminate to the end.

Allah is merciful and benevolent. He created us therefore He knows us better than anyone. Like I mentioned previously, we don't know which one of our actions may please Allah the most. He is also the most forgiving, so no matter even if you are evil, if you honestly want forgiveness and want to mend your ways, then do ask for repentence.

Therefore, in conclusion, I would say and personally believe (for you it could be different), that we should strive to become better beings. Be just, fair and honest in our conduct. Ask for true forgiveness and work upon being better people. This life is a test and there are certain guidelines which have been asked of us (5 pillars) and we should try to achieve those as best we can.

Buddy you are just messing with me arent you? :hehe: Sounds more like the godfather.

Out of respect for you and your murshid, my brother, I’ll shut up :hehe:

Thank you, it makes sense.

But why create such a horrible place where people will suffer and burn for enernity? What good is that going to do? Why create something which is prone to making the wrong choices, why make temptations and traps, and then when the person falls into them, they would be given the torments noone can even imagine.

Like hareem said, life is a test. What are being tested for? Our creator is flawless and could well have created us flawless. Why leave margin for error and then punish what you created?

Re: Some questions

^^

No im not messing around with you. I thought alot before i opened up about this.Most of the people are not aware of certain things. since you dont seem interested, maybe i should shut up.

suger-candy

dude.. the whole drama was not created with a consent of any tasbeeh playing dude.

the reaons and dynamics might not be in theology.

there are MILLION signs in qur'an which are more close to physics then any thing else.

So as our body has more to it then just our thinking, universe has more to it then just theology,

Re: Some questions

Aren't the traps and temptations a part of the test? To see whether we exercise our free will in a positive manner or a negative manner?

If we go back to the the Creation story, we were flawless up until a certain point. Yet due to our own arrogance we succumbed to the one thing which we were asked not to do. So could we not say we as humans are flawed since then? Furthermore, some of the suffering which does take place, is it not created by ourselves?

A test in that this life is temporary. Think of it as an entrance exam for what is to come (the Akhirah)

Whilst I agree, why does suffering occur when we do have Allah, I have not been able to figure that out for myself but would akin it to life being a test.

Re: Some questions

You are not getting me. What I am asking is, what is the purpose of this whole episode of creation, testing and judgement? What good is this going to do anyone? What is this entry exam for? Did he not know that we will do what we are told not to do?

And then the whole concept of creating unimaginable torture chambers i.e. the hell. Why would he want to torture such insignificant creations as us?

And you know what, I am feeling very guilty for asking these questions. I just thought one of our r&s regulars might have pondered and researched these basic questions.

Kimmy-Nibble

dude...If you dont know something then dont assume, please either zip it or ask :)

Re: Some questions

SC dude

answer are not where ppl look for them.

spooky music