Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)
And where did you jump to that conclusion… Yazeed asked for alligance to Imam Hussain A.S. and he didn’t give it… and apparently yazeed ordered to kill him… Had you bothered to read the incident of Kerbala… you would know there were some sahaba of Imam Husain who were killed also… But yeah Imam Husain stood up because he is Imam…
But yeah if you want to know why did Imam Husain didn’t give alligance..let me quote you what I said earlier..in case your ignorant eyes missed it.
Astagfirullah… Do you have any idea what you just said… Nauzubillah Imam Hussan was unable to protect Islam from Yazeed… Do you have any idea what the incident of Kerbala is all about… You said such a big thing so easily… When asked by Imam Zain ul Abideen the son Of Imam Hussain A.S. if his father won and lost the battle of Kerbala, Imam asked him to go and pray two rakat in the mosque, after he came back from the prayers, Imam said till the time this prayers are alive its victory of Imam Hussain A.S.
To sumarize you in short Imam Husain didn’t just fight Yazeed for khilafat or what ever…from what I have learnt from Maulana in majlises and a small prespective I PERSONALLY developed…he raised voice against the system that had developed after Holy Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. After his death whoever came to the throne was regarded Amir ul Momineen irrespective of how did he become Khaleefa. Imam Husain Knew Yazeed was not at all the right person and if he will give alligance he could have introduced alot of bidats..but if Imam Husain would have defeated Yazeed in the battle history probably would have said it was a fight between two princes for the throne and true maqsad of Imam Husain A.S. would have never came forward, but Imam therefore sacrificed his own life and his family in Kerbala with three days of hunger and thirst… and what Yazeed did with the ladies of family of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H.. things like taking their hijab… taking them around the streets of Koofa and shaam… made a show out of them… was clear enough to open the eyes… that anyone who becomes khaleefa is not Amir ul Momineen..this is just my PERSONAL prespective along with several other intensions Imam might have had … Again I am no Alim or maulana to give a bigger or better picture… May Allah forgive me If i don’t do a good job explaining it… or some other issues…Ameen
By the way Asayb… I am still waiting on your answers… ???