Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)
"Considering Quran is compiled in the order it was revealed why is not this ayat towards the end...Does it mean to sunnis... Islam was completed in verse 5:3... what does rest of the ayats mean to you than? "
As we all know Allah is a protector of quran himself there no dought about that. its Allah's will that what Quran we have and in what sequance its in.
If you all have any dought of Allah's claim of protection of Quran in any way either there are some missing "Ayat" or in a squences, then your not objecting any group of islam your are objecting Allah"
Texan_Dude
the things you have asked me. i will only give you one answar no matter what Prophet Muhammed(SAWW) has said about Hazrat Ali and his sons they do not go beyond Prophet Muhammed (SAWW) Sunnah and Hadis.
and the refrence your are giveing about these mullanas they are not prophets that what they writtin is becom some kind of word of Allah and we cannot object on it.
Quote
"At one place you mentioned that its Allah SWT who makes one cry and on the other side you said Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. asked not to mourn on the deceased? why would he stop someone when like you said Its Allah SWT who makes one cry?"
its not i am saying its Ahdis and what you are trying to say these are all wrong? and in these "Ahdis" is there some where written you shold mourn every year.
and what do you think Hazrat Husan was embraced shahadt or he was just died?
and about you said romers all these things are told me none other then you shia brothers.
"IMAM" as far as i know "Imam" means the person who lead Namaz and other muslim follow him as we call Namaz Ba Jmat.
"Imam" as a protector of islam i have heard it before this first time i got chance to ask from you shia, is this mentioned some where in Quran?
about Gazwa khandq, tell me who dig those khandaq's only Prophet Mohammed (SAWW) and Hazrat Ali(AS) and what about other shabas they all jest said " sorry Prophet Muhammed (SAWW) we are not with you in this battle and you are your own"
you people talk unbelievable things when kofar was going to attack muslim in madina one of shaba (which i forgot his name) give an idea of diging khandqas which Prophet muhmmad(SAWW) liked the idea and implement it, and as far as i know all shahbas toke part in this.
and other thing it was only Gazwa Khandq when Islam was in trouble what about gazwa Badar Gazwa Ohad.
Above is mentioned that "IMAM" means is protector of islam and History is witness that when Islam was in trouble Imam came and protect islam, what about event of Karbla if Hazrat Hussan was protector of islam why he was unable to protect the islam from Yazed.
What about in Time of "Changaz Khan" when he broutly killed lots of muslims and Islam was in trouble which IMAM came to protect Islam, then when Islam was in trouble in spain which IMAM came there to protect Islam and about history of subcontinent when muslims where in trouble Which Imam came then to protect Islam and what about now we are in trouble who will come to protect us now?
Its not Islam in trouble its muslim who gets in trouble because they dont follow the path of Prophet Muhammed(SAWW). Islam cannot get in trouble as long as as Quran is protected by Allah.
(Please Allah forgive me if i have said some thing wrong)