Re: Some common misconceptions about Shi’ism(merged)
Didn’t Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. said excuse my words I don’t remember the exact words I am no alim or maulana, The relation of mine with Ali is the same as Haroon to Musa. The only difference is there won’t be any Prophet after me…
You want to compare Hazrat Ali A.S. with Hazrat Omar.
** Tell me who has the honor to born in the house of God(Qaba).**
** Tell me who was honored with sword (Zulfiqar) by Allah SWT**
** Tell me who slept on the bed of Propeht Mohammad P.B.U.H. on the night of Hijrat.s**
** Tell me which of his companion did Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. take in Mubahila.. when he was asked to curse on liars.**
** Tell me who had the honor to perform the funeral services of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H.**
** Tell me who was the Alamdar of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. who let to the victory in Khyber.**
** Tell me who was the only Companion of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. who stood against Umar Ibne Abduwad in the battle of Khandaq.**
** Tell me who stood by Prophet MOhammad P.B.U.H. till the end in the battle of Ohad.**
** Tell me who was chosen to be the son in law of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H.**
Just shows how ignorant you are… No shia doubts in the authenticity of Quran… Allah is the protector and that is the reason there aren’t any other versions of Quran out there like Bible… And if you don’t agree if Quran is not compiled in the order it was revealed… may be you can use your scholarly knowledge to explain this talib-e-Ilm… why is the following ayat is in 5:3 and not all the way in the end
“Today I have perfected your religion and completed my favour upon you, and I was satisfied that Islam be your religion.” (Qur’an 5:3)
Considering Quran is compiled in the order it was revealed why is not this ayat towards the end…Does it mean to sunnis… Islam was completed in verse 5:3… what does rest of the ayats mean to you than?
I don’t want to degrade any sahaba but its amazing like you said “Sahaba” prayed to Allah for shadat… but from what I know about Khandaq… no one else besides Maula Ali A.S stood up when Prophet asked three times who will fight Umar Ibne Abduwad… Anywayzz thats not my point… Like you said Shadat is the greatest gift of Allah.. I don’t want to disagree with you… but can you explain… why do we celebrate Bakar Eid rather than mourn.. Hazrat Ismail was so close to getting the so called greatest gift of Allah S.W.T. why not mourn rather than celebrate Hazrat Ismail not getting this greatest gift…
Crying on the Incident of Kerbala is not just about shadat of Imam Hussain… when asked by Imam Zain ul Abideen A.S.. he said his suffering was most during Shaam..where the grand daughters of Propeht Mohammad P.B.U.H. were roamed around without chadar… such a sad incident… Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. who is our beloved Prophet .. his family was killed with 3 days of hunger and thirst. After his shadat the ladies of his family were taken around the street of koofa and shaam without rida… you want us to love Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H and celebrate rather than mourn on such a sad day of Islamic history ?
Can you tell me did Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. take out processions, with green flags on 12 of Rabiul Awal… has he mentioned it any where? Its amazing sunni believe Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. was born and died on the same day but they celebrate the wiladat… rather than mourn on such a big loss.
The year Hazrat Abu Talib A.S and Hazrat Khadeeja died… didn’t Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. sorrowed for a whole year…known as Youm-e-Huzn.
You need to learn alot more about muttah before commenting… its like a temporary marriage… which was practiced during the time of Prophet… if you get in detail..there is a lot to it… the haqooq of each other… haq mehar… wat about kids born from the practice.the wirasat…there is no way u can link it to prostitution or something… if the concept of temporary marriage was not allowed in islam can you explain me what do youc all the clause of divorce… wat if someone marries a woman… and after a week give her haq mehar and divorce… now wat would you call that.
Go and learn about things before you start using these forums to spread rumors… Talking about religon is a sensitive issue.. and make sure you know what you are talking about… I have read a number of things in this forums that are about shiasm..and most of them are just rumors… Which disappoints me most.. people here are so good in spreading rumors..without looking into its authenticity..you hear from someone and boom..Its gotta be rite… and they call themselves muslims…and what saddens me the most if its because of the rumors spread by these kinds of people…shias specially in pakistan eventhough a minority they are victim of sunni terrorism… its amazing how many sister have been widowed and kids are being orphaned because of such rumors out there… I have had someone send me this link where it talked about nauzubillah shia doubting the Prophet hood of Mohammad… quran and god knows wat and at the end its asked to help them join this war against shiasm or something eventhough i don’t recall any single thing i read on the site was correct or is being practiced.. and even killing others is not the teaching of Prophet Mohammad P.B.U.H. a lady used to throw stones at Prophet he never ordered to kill her but went for her ayadat when she was sick..these are the teaching and sunnah of my beloved Prophet P.B.U.H. Let Allah SWT be the judge… Please if you guys have any thing productive to say give references… I just read a post earlier by ArMughal claiming shias don’t pay zakat..without any references to book where the teaching of Zakat is prohibited in shiasm.. we do, its just we don’t brag than give.
I am sorry if I offended anyone.. I didn’t intend too…
May Allah forgive us for our sins and help us all follow the Right path…Ameen
www.al-islam.org/ghadir/
http://www.al-islam.org/peshawar/
http://www.al-islam.org/nahj/
http://www.al-islam.org/guided/