Sindhiya main Sikandar

Very well researched work :k:

Salman Rashid

Sindhia mein Sikander - the documentary - spread over thirteen episodes each of 30 minutes was about Alexander’s Indian Campaign. We joined Alexander at Nawagai (Bajaur), and followed him through Pakistan to Makran where he left the country. The original idea to write a book germinated when I was researching for my book The Salt Range and the Potohar Plateau during the mid-1990s. I tried to get funding from National Fund for Culture and Heritage but at that time Dani was heading the fund and he was like the proverbial snake in the treasure-house - repugnant to the idea of spending the money. But after the success of Nagri, Nagri Ghoom Musafir, Muneeza Hashmi who was then GM PTV Lahore asked for another idea. I suggested Alexander and she fought very hard with the MD Yusuf Baig Mirza for financing for the project. The rest, as they say, is history.

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

Alexander in Multan – The Express Tribune

Back in 2001, when I was making the PTV documentary Sindhia mein Sikander (on Alexander’s Indian campaign), I discovered a large body of local myth. One was the ridiculous pride that everyone took in the fact that Alexander of Macedonia tarried in their village for ‘six months’ — always six, never more, nor less. The other, a Multan-centric one, was about how the people of that city killed the conqueror.

Having sailed down the Jhelum from the vicinity of Mandi Bahauddin, to its junction with the Chenab near Jhang, Alexander made forced marches across what was then sand desert, through modern Toba Tek Singh to Kamalia, Tulumba and eventually Multan — “the principal town of the Mallian people”, as the historian Arrian tells us.

The city of Multan lay around the lofty battlements of a strongly fortified citadel with two perimeter walls that stood in the area taken by the tomb of Rukne Alam today. Alexander led the attack with one division supported by another, under his general Perdiccas. Alexander’s troops managed to take down a gate, massive as it must have been, penetrating into the first corridor.

As the foreigners milled about in the corridor between the two defensive walls, they saw above them the battlements virtually crawling with the defenders. As Alexander ordered sapping operations, he also called for scaling ladders to be put up against the walls. Impetuous as he was, Alexander did not like the slow progress. Snatching a ladder from the man carrying it, Alexander personally placed it against the wall and, crouching under his shield, clambered up to the crenulations.

Immediately behind him was Peucestas, carrying the sacred shield that Alexander always used in battle. Following Peucestas was Leonnatus, the king’s personal bodyguard.

Having reduced the defenders on the battlements, Alexander stood on the crenulations in full view of both the defenders and his own troops. While his troops were hurrying to join him on the fort walls, Alexander jumped inside the fort where he met the best of the Rajput troops from Multan and as far away as Rajasthan. In the thick of this battle, as he raised his sword arm to strike an adversary, an arrow from a Multani archer found its target.

The arrow, having pierced his corselet, lodged in his breast on the right side. Alexander fell. We are told that he bled from the mouth, the blood being mixed with air bubbles, meaning that his lung was punctured. There is then a very moving heroic scene preserved in the histories: Perdiccas standing astride the still body, protecting it with the shield of Achilles, and Leonnatus desperately holding off the attackers.

Meanwhile, Alexander’s panicked soldiers had gained the wall by escalade. Soon the gates were thrown open and the fort taken. Though he gave his army a fright, Alexander did not die. He made it back by the skin of his teeth. This was September 326 BCE.

Four years later, in June 322, Alexander died apparently of a fever in Babylon. In between the injury in Multan and his final exit from near Gwadar, Alexander fought several battles, notably those of Rahim Yar Khan, Sehwan and Hyderabad. And he survived the horrendous march across the parched wastes of Makran. Yet so many in Multan believe he died of their arrow.

It is said, in jest of course, that the Multani phrase ‘karay saan,’ (will do) means something may (or may not) get done in the next several years after the utterance. I joke with my Multani friends that if they want to believe it was their arrow that killed the Macedonian, then we must also take the *karay saan *joke at face value. Surely only such an arrow could have taken four years to kill a man.

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

But why Alexander the great, is called Sikander and popular in muslims?

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

I think its Arbanised version of Alexander's name. Like Egyptian city founded by him is now Iskandria (Alexandria)

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

But I don’t think his empire ever covered Egypt :confused:

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

Alexandria was founded around a small pharaonic town c. 331 BC by Alexander the Great. It became an important centre of the Hellenistic civilization and remained the capital of Hellenistic and Roman & Byzantine Egypt for almost one thousand years until the Muslim conquest of Egypt in AD 641, when a new capital was founded at Fustat (later absorbed into Cairo).

Alexandria - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Somehow till the time of Cleopatra, Egypt remained under rulers who were not Greek :confused:

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

So in general, who is considered hero in Pakistan, Alexander the great or Porus??

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

Sikandar... We love imported invaders :p

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

you can find more in the movie Alexandar

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

movies wlai history :nahi:

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

Right :k:…is tarhan to Islamabad ka bhi Sikandar tha

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

That Sikandar is recent past, not history.

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

why isn't a missile named after him then?

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

Good question. Because He was not a Muslim who made lives of Hindus troublesome :)

Though some people believe that 'Dhul-Qarnain' as mentioned in Quran was Alexander.

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

But Invaders raided and looted everyone. This remind me of Kashmiri tale, an old muslim of Kashmir once told me, when pathans came to valley in 47, they broke people teeth, if it were gold plated, the other concluded saying that pathans were so dumb that they couldn't differentiate between brass and gold. So oldman, who was young then, rushed away towards shehr, srinagar, because pathans looted entire bazaars :)

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

People have short memory. Abdali looted Muslims as well, even Muslim Sufi Poet Bulleh Shah condemned him 'Khada Peeta wahi da, baki Ahmed Shahi da', but still we got Abdali missiles.

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

The day that India starts naming places/buildings/weapons after our looters will be the day that I will give up my Indian citizenship in sorrow and tar my head in shame. I would rather have something named after home grown country men. Even bigoted viruses like Aurangazeb is preferable than some non regional who made my ancestor's life a misery.

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

salman rashid has a good grasp over history and i respect him for that other wise he is a ‘bad tameez aadmi’. I have added him on twitter and keep on seeing him utter rubbish.

You can find his blog here: odysseuslahori.blogspot.com

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

lols. badtameez aadmi. I think people in our part can’t bear burden of knowledge and become arrogant

Re: Sindhiya main Sikandar

If you want to follow him here he is on twitter. @odysseuslahori