Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Go ahead
Okay, first let me tell U tale of two nations, that are called India and Pakistan. Do U feel that hindus in Pakistan have been granted same rights just like muslims in India? Not to tell anyone that hindus are majority and driving force behind India just like muslims are in Pakistan. Who are more tolerant and open to give religious freedom to their counterparts? are they hindus in India or Muslims in Pakistan?
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Okay, first let me tell U tale of two nations, that are called India and Pakistan. Do U feel that hindus in Pakistan have been granted same rights just like muslims in India? Not to tell anyone that hindus are majority and driving force behind India just like muslims are in Pakistan. Who are more tolerant and open to give religious freedom to their counterparts? are they hindus in India or Muslims in Pakistan?
I think yes. Hindus got rights in Pakistan and there are Hindus who could reach the positions such as Chief Justice of Supreme Court of Pakistan. Having said that there is still room for big improvements and we need to work on harmony between different religion and sects. The situation may have deteriorated in recent years, but that doesn't mean that minorities always remained under risk in Pakistan.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
I think yes. Hindus got rights in Pakistan and there are Hindus who could reach the positions such as Chief Justice of Supreme Court of Pakistan. Having said that there is still room for big improvements and we need to work on harmony between different religion and sects. The situation may have deteriorated in recent years, but that doesn't mean that minorities always remained under risk in Pakistan.
Its U who brought out issue of a hindu being chief justice of Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
Brother, can U tell me what is logic behind making him, who dont even believe in truthfulness of the holy prophet, chief justice of Islamic republic of Pakistan? doesnt it shows that policy makers in ur Nation have some real problem in understanding right things?
Its not about making someone chief justice, but giving him equal rights like muslims. Do hindus in Pakistan have same political rights as muslims have in India?
Do hindus or christians or any other religious minority have religious rights in Pakistan as muslims in India have?
These are two questions to start with, rest will follow only after U will answer them properly.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Its U who brought out issue of a hindu being chief justice of Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
Brother, can U tell me what is logic behind making him, who dont even believe in truthfulness of the holy prophet, chief justice of Islamic republic of Pakistan? doesnt it shows that policy makers in ur Nation have some real problem in understanding right things?
Its not about making someone chief justice, but giving him equal rights like muslims. Do hindus in Pakistan have same political rights as muslims have in India?
Do hindus or christians or any other religious minority have religious rights in Pakistan as muslims in India have?
These are two questions to start with, rest will follow only after U will answer them properly.
what kind of religious rights do you think are not available to Pakistani minorities? Can't they pray in their temples and churches.
Regarding your sarcastic comment for making a Hindu Chief Justice of Pakistan ( Rana Bhgwan Das), I would say kisi haal main khush nahi log. na banae to masla , banae to bhi masla.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Its U who brought out issue of a hindu being chief justice of Islamic Republic of Pakistan.
Brother, can U tell me what is logic behind making him, who dont even believe in truthfulness of the holy prophet, chief justice of Islamic republic of Pakistan? doesnt it shows that policy makers in ur Nation have some real problem in understanding right things?
Its not about making someone chief justice, but giving him equal rights like muslims. Do hindus in Pakistan have same political rights as muslims have in India?
Do hindus or christians or any other religious minority have religious rights in Pakistan as muslims in India have?
These are two questions to start with, rest will follow only after U will answer them properly.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
what kind of religious rights do you think are not available to Pakistani minorities? Can't they pray in their temples and churches.
Regarding your sarcastic comment for making a Hindu Chief Justice of Pakistan ( Rana Bhgwan Das), I would say kisi haal main khush nahi log. na banae to masla , banae to bhi masla.
Good question brother.
See for instance, a non-muslim cant become ur prime minister or president, its a gross violation of rights of a citizen according to Indian constitution. In India even Muqawwee can fight election against Manmohan Singh or even against Narendra Modi, while such concessions are not granted to pakistani minorities.
A hindu or a christian can pray in temple or elsewhere, admitted, but he cant hold out a religious procession doing all the nare bazi and muscle flexing, this concession is available to all in India including muslims. Although I m personally against slogan shouting or religious processions or muscle flexing.
In India we have likes of dr. Zakir Naiks or other pious muslims who openly try to revert ppls of other religion including hindus to Islam, while in Pakistan, there is no such concessions to non-muslims.
And comment about chief justice, is not sarcastic but realistic if U go deep into it. Tell me, do Rana Bhagvan Das believe in Naboowat of the holy prophet? if not, whats the point in making him chief justice of a land where Islamic laws are to be implemented? Isnt it a joke? PLz come clean on it.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Good question brother.
See for instance, a non-muslim cant become ur prime minister or president, its a gross violation of rights of a citizen according to Indian constitution. In India even Muqawwee can fight election against Manmohan Singh or even against Narendra Modi, while such concessions are not granted to pakistani minorities.
A hindu or a christian can pray in temple or elsewhere, admitted, but he cant hold out a religious procession doing all the nare bazi and muscle flexing, this concession is available to all in India including muslims. Although I m personally against slogan shouting or religious processions or muscle flexing.
In India we have likes of dr. Zakir Naiks or other pious muslims who openly try to revert ppls of other religion including hindus to Islam, while in Pakistan, there is no such concessions to non-muslims.
And comment about chief justice, is not sarcastic but realistic if U go deep into it. Tell me, do Rana Bhagvan Das believe in Naboowat of the holy prophet? if not, whats the point in making him chief justice of a land where Islamic laws are to be implemented? Isnt it a joke? PLz come clean on it.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
When you portray poor minority of pakistan.....
please try to count dead bodies of poor sunni muslim belonging to majority who are also victim of terrorism in pakistan.....
And please give me the post number where i said pakistani muslims are more tolerant than indian hindus let me edit it....
And who were the killers of those poor sunni or shia muslims? were they hindus from India other non-muslims from elsewhere? who is responsible for their killing except wrong brand of religious education? if yes, than who provided that kind of religious education? is it kuffar India?
Who were the terrorists and where they got their lessons from? any idea?
And if U really will to edit it, than its not an issue with me,. we all say something wrong in our day-to-day lives, its important we admit our mistakes.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
And who were the killers of those poor sunni or shia muslims? were they hindus from India other non-muslims from elsewhere? who is responsible for their killing except wrong brand of religious education? if yes, than who provided that kind of religious education? is it kuffar India?
A nation goes through different stages....ever heard about american civil war...
that does not make all muslims intolerant...
why dont you talk about condition of dalits in India
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
The minorities should leave Pakistan, but they should keep in mind that there are many places within India (like Mumbai) where even Indian Muslims cant find houses to rent.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Pakistan was not like this till the 80's. The area forming Pakistan and Afghanistan has always been part of great games. The games continue the players have changed (Iran, Saudia, India and US). There are issues within today's Pakistan and the good thing is that people are discussing them, the situation will hopefully improve with the passage of time. It would have been more alarming if people were shying away from the issues.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
A nation goes through different stages....ever heard about american civil war...
that does not make all muslims intolerant...
why dont you talk about condition of dalits in India
I dont talk about dalits in India coz U havent ordered me yet, just kidding.
Okay lets talk about dalit. Dalit who was considered untouchable in India. Who was not allowed to go to temples in India. Who was not allowed to sit with upper casts in India.
Past is past, good ppls learn from their past mistakes, and not stick to those mistakes out of their arrogance.
Havent U ever heard of Mayawati? elected ex chief minister of largest populated state in India? which houses more ppls than in Pakistan. What else U need to learn that past if over now? we are proud citizens of new India who have shunned such bad practices. Go and learn about how many brahmins are with her? how many other upper cast ppls are with her? Where the issue of dalits remains in India after such empowerment of dalits?
Dont U know Ms. Meera Kumar our speaker of parliament is a dalit?
Dont U know that R.K. Narainan our president was a dalit?
Dont U know that Chief Justice Balkrishnan was a dalit?
Should I give U more names to make U understand that dalit and anti dalit is no more a issie in India?
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
The minorities should leave Pakistan, but they should keep in mind that there are many places within India (like Mumbai) where even Indian Muslims cant find houses to rent.
I dont expect U to indulge in these kind of false propoganda.
There are places in each and every city in India where even hindus cant find a house on rent, and these are muslim dominated places, where only muslims will be given a house on rent. And no one can object to it coz its the right of the owner of property to decide.
In mumbai, its some dumb head ppls who wont rent out their property to any other than their own religion. this is bad, but not enough to put India in bad light.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
Pakistan was not like this till the 80's. The area forming Pakistan and Afghanistan has always been part of great games. The games continue the players have changed (Iran, Saudia, India and US). There are issues within today's Pakistan and the good thing is that people are discussing them, the situation will hopefully improve with the passage of time. It would have been more alarming if people were shying away from the issues.
Re: Should India welcome all Pakistani minorities who want to leave Pakistan?
I dont talk about dalits in India coz U havent ordered me yet, just kidding.
Okay lets talk about dalit. Dalit who was considered untouchable in India. Who was not allowed to go to temples in India. Who was not allowed to sit with upper casts in India.
Past is past, good ppls learn from their past mistakes, and not stick to those mistakes out of their arrogance.
Havent U ever heard of Mayawati? elected ex chief minister of largest populated state in India? which houses more ppls than in Pakistan. What else U need to learn that past if over now? we are proud citizens of new India who have shunned such bad practices. Go and learn about how many brahmins are with her? how many other upper cast ppls are with her? Where the issue of dalits remains in India after such empowerment of dalits?
Dont U know Ms. Meera Kumar our speaker of parliament is a dalit?
Dont U know that R.K. Narainan our president was a dalit?
Dont U know that Chief Justice Balkrishnan was a dalit?
Should I give U more names to make U understand that dalit and anti dalit is no more a issie in India?
Giving a few examples here and there does not reflect what is going on with the majority of the people within that sect. let me flip this, Benazir was PM of Pakistan twice, Our NA speaker is a woman. Many women are ministers and member of parliament. Does that mean that there are no women related problems in our country. Think about the majority of people and how they are affected and try not to defend everything which is wrong in the country under the guise of nationalism.