Today I was reading TLK’s blog and its true that there is shirk in naats.Its sad because sometime we like naat so much but we don’t understand the meaning of it.Like this naat “Tera karam hai aqaa ke baat ab tak bani hoii hai” is a naat I used to think its a hamd until oneday my hubz told me that it is for Prophet Mohammad (p.b.u.h.) I use to like “na kaleem kaa tassawur naa kayaal-e- toor-e-sina” there is a sentence in it “mein ne kaha ke almadad mohammad, to ubhar gaya Safina (meaning ship)” what does this mean ke Prophet Mohammad(p.b.u.h.) will come and save the drowning ship?Well I use to listen naats but now I am afraid that if I am listening to naats am I listening shirk? :aq:And these naats comes from barelvi tabqaa
Re: Shirk in Naats
not just naats, but also many daroods u will see are filled with shirks :( i.e. Darood-e-Taj
honestly u really have to use ur wisdom and knowledge in order to follow Islam. its not an easy job
and dont just blindly follow what u have been told.
That is true Zobia:(
I heard a great deal about Darood-e-tanjeena but I think only darood-e-Ibrahimi is the best.
Re: Shirk in Naats
Zobia, youknow I was just going through this Punj Surah Shareef book that I have and it has a whole bunch of duroods that seem quite like shirk so I always questioned their authenticity. I guess it's safer just to stick to simple duroods like durood e Ibrahim and simple duas from the Qur'an such the rabbana duas.
Re: Shirk in Naats
ab parain ge jootay UZ pe chaaroN taraf se, for opening this thread :p
Re: Shirk in Naats
The prophet (saw) himself advised us not to worship him and that only Allah (swt) can fulfill all our desires. I guess we humans get carried away. Have love for the Prophet (saw) and follow his sunnah but worship only Allah.
ab parain ge jootay UZ pe chaaroN taraf se, for opening this thread :p
I already have responses in feedback for UZ ready for future war situations :D
koii nahi parein gay jootay mein apnay dictator ko agey ker doon gi unhi kaa blog thaa jis ne mera mind badla 
The prophet (saw) himself advised us not to worship him and that only Allah (swt) can fulfill all our desires. I guess we humans get carried away. Have love for the Prophet (saw) and follow his sunnah but worship only Allah.
Nicely said Nikki that we should have love for Prophet Mohammad (p.b.u.h.) but we should only worship one ALLAh.
dictator ?? 
ooops sorry director boss
yes, it is better to stick with daroord-e-Ibrahimi.
ppl try to get some out of the world duas in the belief of getting extra sawab.
i mean why dont ppl stick to the know ones :S
see this…i dont know how many more daroods exist 
Re: Shirk in Naats
unbelievable.
I though it was about the quality not quantity 
Zobia kitnay tarah ke darood hain 
ya we are so helpless that we cant even raise our voice against the ones who hijacked our religion 
fiker na kerin UZ…danda is ready 
…and so is TLK’s ban button 
lagta hai app ko wo letters nahi milaiy…jin ko perhanay k baad ager app 7 din tek pata nahi kia perha kerin to pata nahi kitnay loug mer jayain gain…and then u also need to fwd them (lol..i got such letter in grade three or main to yakeen ker chuki thee k main to fout hogayee hoon)
honestly…i am seeing these things since my childhoods. darood books, marsia books, naat books
ya ALLAH is quaom ko rah-e-rast per la. Ameen
Re: Shirk in Naats
kia sub naat shirk hain? aur woh ju tv par aa ti hain...ramzan kai time aur woh ju Junaid Jamshed ki naat etc..woh theek hain?
Re: Shirk in Naats
^ yeah plz sum1 answer that!
and get ready for rampage!
Junaid Jamshed ki nasheeds theek hain kyoon ke un mein shirk nahi magar bohat dehaan saa sunna parta hai