Re: Shia Sunni Dialogue
Now talking about the combination of Body and soul, my believe is that this body is the dress of our soul, when we'll leave this world we shall remove the dress and GO BACK, to where we came from,
Again this soul may live outside this world, but, it may have no powers nor allowed to interfere in wordly affairs. Niether their is any logic of granting these souls any powers to do so. As different creation (the Angels) are created to do these tasks and they also perform all those on the order of Allah Subhan.o.tala and not on their on will.
PS: please let me know if i had missed any point
Brother Hanibal
May the blessings of Allah shower upon you...
Now i think our discussion is on such point where it should have to be clear that Souls have any sorts of power or not.. As we both agrees on that Souls are alive and eat and drink and so on..... So if it become clear that whether souls have some power to help us or not then we will be close enough to find the right answer of this discussion... So please let me compile the verses and Ahadees and Seerat e Sahaba for the regarding matter then i shall write on this topic.. But due to this extensive research it might take a day or two and i hope you would not mind it and will pray for me that i may get the rightous path...
For the time being i want to ask a question from your post... You stated that The Salams Allah Almighty has sent on Prophets are just sort of appraisal and in then you said that we ask Allah Almighty to show us the path of those who are praised by Almighty...
**
My Question is that in Sora e Fatiha the word Allah used is "Anumta Aleihim" And i am being a very ordinary student of Arabic language may translate it into "Jin ko Neimat die gai"... In Salam's Allah sent i couldnt found any context where it has given that those were the persons who got the Neimat.... And again you would agree with me that IF ANYONE ASKS US TO FOLLOW OF PATH OF SOMEONE WE WOULD ASK THAT TO WHOM WE HAVE TO FOLLOW SHOULD BE IN FRONT OF US OTHERWISE WE CANNOT FOLLOW SO TELL ME WHERE ARE THOSE PRAISED PERSON WHICH YOU CLAIMED ARE BEING PRAYED TO SHOW THEIR PATH....**