Shia brothers please answer: Why would Umar/Uthman R.A compile Quran?

[MAKRANI]

Re: Shia brothers please answer: Why would Umar/Uthman R.A compile Quran?

@smooth_guy

Both of these answers are first time I am hearing. Please provide exact reference to the hadith book. It would be interesting to see what Sunni Ulema will have to say about it. I will consult one once you provide a concrete proof. So far it looks like a familiar routine rebuttal from Shias to divert the question.

Moreover, stick to the question and answer it. Was it not compiled during Umar./Uthman era and do you guys think the book in your house is in complete form and there is nothing hidden in that cave.

You never enlightened us with what your ulema had to say about those two hadiths.

If you look at any hadith in sahih books you will notice that majority of hadiths are listed with many variations. These hadiths were narrated by sahabas based on their memory hence you will notice variations. Just imagine same sahabas memorizing the Quran when it was not even in a book form and helping compile the holy book without any mistake. I think not.

It was definitely compiled in the Prophet’s time by somebody who was called “talking Quran or Quran e natiq”. When Prophet pbuh said I am leaving behind two things Book and my Ahlulbait he definitely did not mean different verses memorized by different people or the Book that was burned by third Caliph later. Prophet pbuh had the responsibility and he fulfilled it right, not just left it for others do it for him.

Please stop mocking Islam.