Re: Sheikh Abdul Qadir Gillani
sir...abu bakr..umar ..usman and ali are the 4 greatest sahabas...but they did not know the names of hypocrites but ...huzaifa bin alyaman knew...
abu bar and usman did not know abut fiqah much as lower sahabi like muaz bin jabal..and ibne abbas ..a child aty that time....
every man is unique ..and have differnet characteristics....
so if some sahabas have kash ..dosent means that...every sahabi must have kashf....
plus..its need increased when there were not sahabas..as when time passed piousness decreased...so there was need of kasf and karamat..and miracles...to keep peole emracing islam..specially in your country...jai pal..was a very big magician..to beat him..allah gaveKhawaja Moin ud din chisti the same miracles to beat him..so that...hindus embraceed ilam to very large extent....
dont confuse miracle with that..they are with will of a person.,.not at all..its all diue to allah's will..and shear folowing of sunnah plus nafal ibadat....
and saudis ..i give thier name again ..and again..as they totally deny all things..and call it bidaat ..kufr..deviancy etc etc....
when a man is not given such power..the best option for him..is to deny that thing....for example..if a man cannot complete the post doc....in age of 24 or 23 in these times..but not impossible..so if anybody do that..rest dont believe that..and call him...liar..a natural consequence..same is the ase with ahle hadees..or wahabi schaolars..since they are not giftede with these ..so anyone who claims hat..is a liar in thier eyes...
Regarding the bold part you shud also know the who told him the name of the hypocrites and there is a complete story behind it, its not like he could know the unseen which is an attribute of Allaah and its the Prophet who told him.
Umar ra how did he notice the they wer kafirs when he used to go to some muslims death and if huzaifa was absent he would turn back as he knew that huzaifa knew who were hypocites or not.
Secondly i agree with you complete unless we cant experience you cant really try to picturize this. Regarding your argument regarding the other scholars such as wahabis ahle hadith deny is an old argument of oour indo-pak scholars. Dekho hamare buzurg ko yeh hua tha lekin tumko nahi hua and they end they conclude Allaah loves them more compared to wahabis and ahle hadith.
Secondly miracle, karamat is no where found in the hadith of the Prophet i mean authentic hadith not indo-pak manufactured hadith.(according to my observation over a period of time i have noticed you belong to the deobandi sect (believe me i can go ga ga over them only from the book of fadhail e amal and when i read the stories after each virtue is mentioned thats enough for me to say)
I dont wanna get into sectarian rift here neither you nor i can prove each one of them wrong, now i wanna know why do these people have to get into kashf when none of the sahabas were told to do so or allowed to do so and here is where i am asking you for hadith.
And divine dont write stories now, you know i am not going to believe get me authentic proof and prove me wrong and believe me if you prove me wrong i will be the first to accept your ideology