Shariah march in UK

The whole purpose of this exercise is to establish what you mean by ideology. I can look it up in a dictionary however that doesnt help me when talking to someone who anthropromorphises ‘ideology’. You seem to suggest the difference is that ideologies are supposed to be political. Is that correct? Since the definitions you posted would fit any major religion of the world.

You claim that Islamists back this individual, and the 40-50% back this individual. That is completely unfounded. I wager the individual would struggle to muster up 100 acquaintances let alone be a global player in a planetwide game.

40% of Muslims in the UK have not to my knowledge wanted to impose shariah law over UK and convert trafalgar square to a wuzu center. Polls usually have been with reference to shariah facilities being provided in parts of Britain where there is a significant population of Muslims, similar to Jewish courts, a move that the Archbishop of Canterbury has backed. Hardly a very radical position. It is unfounded to regard that as evidence of support for this individual.

You lack specificity in everything. One “islamist”/Muslim/Communist is the same as every “Islamist”/Muslim/Communist in the world. Soviets and Chinese would both trace their ideologies to Marx, but had important figures that dramatically changed their ideologies thereafter (Lenin/Stalin/Mao). Each “Islamist” that you lump together with every random Muslim who happens to believe whatever he believes may have dramatically different views about very important things. But they’re all the same to you.

Fact that there is no “male” “female” “asian” “brown” or “adult” ideology doesnt matter. Each of these categories can be motivations for behaviour in a certain way. You blame Islam for the behaviour of a small group of people, and link anyone sharing some of the background to the terrorists. This lack of specificity for such a large group of people is extremely obtuse reasoning. 1/5th of the world is Muslim, lets say 1/2 of the world is male. Feminists can (and have) argued along the lines as you.

There are good arguments to be made on the issue of religious extremism and attitudes towards violence. You arent making them on this thread.

I’ll go with the first of what you posted. This would include religions. Yes communism was an ideology, and as per your definition, a global ideology. Since you have asked the question four times, let me ask you, what is the point?

If people were being reductive, yes.

Effectively anyone who shares any beliefs with anyone else is under the same ideology. Fine. I’ll work with the broad brush.

Would the actions of a social democrats in Pakistan have the backing of social democrats in Britain? Social democrats in south america have recently been pretty violent. Should social democrats in the UK be viewed with suspicion?

BS. There has been a lot more shia-sunni/sunni-sunni violence than there has been violence against westerners.

Absolutely. And similar marriages of convenience have spanned religious/ideological boundaries in that region. Whether it is support for Christian militia in Lebanon (Iran), support for secular militia like Jondollah (Saudi arab/US), it is all about local motivations than some cogent connected global organism, where one person photoshopping trafalgar square is equated with, and has the backing of anyone who has a beard in Iran and Afghanistan.