what do you guys think because i have heard that its not allowed but why do many girls do iti.
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
as per sahih hadith, its strictly forbidden....
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
sorry, aishaindubai you can't keep your beautful eyes, beautiful any more.
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
what:confused:
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
Can you quote that Sahih Hadith, Mughal
It seems to me that every thing we do these days under the sun is forbidden by some Sahih Hadith. Are we on a path tangent to the prophet's direction? Or these directions are really from the prophet or some impostor in between?
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
why do u feel this way???
it really aint that hard to stick to Islam…
u know what is meant by the verse “ya ayyuhalazina aamanu, udkhulu fis-silmi kaafa”???
it means follow Islam completely and dont pick and choose, hey eyebrows shaping is a fashion so lets take it up and dump the hadith, and its easy to put question marks on hadith so we’ll get away with it…
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
MKF that is true that most of the things we do these days are fobidden but do we follow islam??? no we do whatever we feel like so what is the argument about??? if you really want to find out about what is forbidden and what is not than go and do some research!! i am not a religious person my self but i do believe that their is a reason behind every foribdding so b4 saying any thing i think you should do some research gain some knowledge about islam and its rules and than say some thing i dont mean it in horrible way you might already know alot more than me but still i would say that go and do some research on internet read sahi bukhari and you will find out what is wrong and what is right :) coz its really easy for us to say that islam is very strict or every thing is forbidden but non of us try and find out why it is like that coz its really easy to get carried away with the luxuries (we want to believe or want things to be the way we want them) of life but its hard to believe/feel the hardship of our Prophet (PBU) and his companions lives
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
If they become really big, double the size then its ok, but otherwise its not allowed.
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
yeah and ur jst meant to use threading or waxing
but if ur eyebrows are REALLY big then ur allowed
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
explains all the monobrows in pakistan
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
I agree that research should be done but i will question any research based only on Sahih bukhari as i am asking this from all my fellows"Is the criteria for establishing a Sahih Hadith rigorous enough" and all answers are simply conjectures nothing concrete.
If someone can prove that the criteria can withstand peer review and scholarly criticism (like done in science which they willingly called collection of Ahadith as science) than definitely it is forbidden but if someone cannot prove than making something forbidden not mentioned in Quran is something tresspassing your authority as religious interpretors
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
so is it forbidden?
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
Salam,
yes Aysha , in hadees there is curse (lanat) on a woman doing this.Well the question why women do this ? there are many things we do which are forbidden , we listen music , we stare on women on tv whereas even second glance is not allowed , i am not blaming anyone paticular , i also do same thing , but many people doing that ,does not means that it becomes allowed…
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
i see these ISlamic professors(women) on t.v who teach QUran and Sunnah but you can tell tehy have theirs done and sometimes i even doubt the Mufit’s for having their so perfectly fine:hoonh:
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
From what I understood it was a prohibition against plucking hairs between the eyebrows. So if you're not born with a semi-unibrow, then its okay, you can walk around the way you are. But if you are born with one, then you can't pluck those brows.
But apparently if you pluck underneath your brows that is okay. But not above the brows.
I don't know the exact details, and I definitely have my eyebrows threaded. I think it depends on how you reason with it. I don't see it as being a really big deal, because it depends what you're doing with it. If you're doing it so you can attract male attention, then that's one thing. You can wear purple boots to attract male attention, and wearing purple boots would then be wrong.
But I do it to look more professional at school and at work, and to be taken seriously. You don't groom yourself, people tend not to take you seriously here. It probably differs according to different cultures, and different time periods.
And I agree with MFK. Some hadith's just don't have any valid reasoning, and some don't seem applicable anymore.
If women who thread eyebrows are going to hell, why did the Quran not mention that? A lanat to hell is a pretty serious thing - I'm sure God would have mentioned it as a cardinal rule that transcends time periods and cultures. Why did he forget to do that, I wonder?
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
Well i 1st got my eyebrows threaded when i got married for my wedding-my eyebrows wernt bad so i didnt feel the need to do them b4 then. Ive heard so many different things abt it though. 1 i heard is that ur meant to get permission off ur husband-i have no idea how true that is..its just something ive heard.
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
And I agree with MFK. Some hadith's just don't have any valid reasoning, and some don't seem applicable anymore.
PCG, you agreed with me but not understood me. i never said that some Ahadeeth are no more applicable. I meant that if they are really the Ahadith narrated by prophet than till qiyamat we have to follow them but if they are doubtful than please be rational. why should we make something halaal as haraam as some idiot after sahabas fabricated on the name of prophet & the sahabas as transmitter to declare somethiing haraam which he did not like.
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
I dont see how it could be haraam. to my knowledge, the Prophet encouraged grooming and looking pleasing, for example when going for jummah prayer.
I think it is very likely that it is sunnah, but to say it is haraam is going over board. I mean, consider the implication of the word haraam, meaning FORBIDDEN. It cant be used carelessly, for trivial things. Anyway, I'd like to see this hadeeth myself.
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
I have asked for the Hadith since start but so far no one has come forward.
Re: Shaping The Eyebrows
what do you mean by size? Is there any standard specified in Fiqh?