Re: Secular Pakistan
My dear Captain 1 -
Islam was the best system - at the time of the Prophet - maybe the 4 caliphs as well.
Theoretically you could argue that it is still the best system.
However the latter part of your comment is key - the current set of Muslims are the worst implementers of this system.
So the question then becomes - do you want a theoretically perfect system to be established by the worst Muslims - the outcome seems like it would slowly gravitate to Swat Taliban type rule.
Or do you want to give secularism - or if that is too extreme for you - moderation a chance - so that people can take a couple of decades to improve their Muslim hood and then decide if they want an Islamic State.
It is my personal opinion that even then an Islamic State - would be in feasible given the number of sects of Islam.