Sects in Islam: How do you explain this?

[psyah]

Re: Sects in Islam: How do you explain this?

@vroom

Wahabi insolence:
Public » Askimam

Question is asked if saying Ya Ahlal Qaboor is ok then why is saying Ya RasoolAllah [SallAllahu Alaihi wa Ahlihi wa Sallam] impermissible according to these bricks

Answer from them: because Barelvis say Ya RasoolAllah [SallAllahu Alaihi wa Ahlihi wa Sallam] believing RasoolAllah SallAllahu Alaihi wa Ahlihi wa Sallam to be Hazir wa Nazir [and he tries implying this is shirk] and it is ‘corrupt’ and ‘non-islamic’ belief. However when you say Ya Ahlal Qabur [from from one end of cemetery to the other] it is not said with any corrupt aqeedah. He says how can one use saying Ya Ahlal Qabur to justify saying Ya RasoolAllah [SallAllahu Alaihi wa Ahlihi wa Sallam] !

I say this is bad manners
I say this is takfiri
I say this is totally void of the Jamaah
I say this is void of the Sunnah
I say this view was taken up [by early deobandis] to cause trouble in the region [troublemakers]

Peace vroom

I dunno … but Deobandis say Ya RasoolAllah (SAW) all the time … in the tashhud …

Assalamu’alaika AyyuhanNabiyu … this is harf nida and ism munada - according to rules of grammar - so if people are saying their aqeedah is wrong I wonder who they are actually saying salam to in their prayers?

Trust me there are ways to convince Deobandis - no need for takfir - just simple internal consistency checks will prove things.