Secret Pakistan

Society Pakistan & World Affairs
1

Has no one watched this rather damning investigation?

It is only available on the BBC so only Uk viewers will be able to see it.

There is no smoke without fire?

2

Re: Secret Pakistan

i found this on youtube…it’s a 6 part series…follow the link:

3

Re: Secret Pakistan

whoa. Thanks, will watch it today.

4

Re: Secret Pakistan

isnt it the same biased docmentary that psyah is talking about here???

http://www.paklinks.com/gs/all-views/526296-bbc-start-a-documentary-mini-series-about-pakistan-and-taliban.html

5

Re: Secret Pakistan

Sometimes there is an effort to divert the smoke else where to hide your own guilt or incompetence.

One thing convinced me how biased it was. In the early days of war Osama was surrounded by American forces in Tora Bora. When the general asked pentagon permission to go in and arrest or kill him, he was asked to pull back? Why??? now we are told in this highly biased documentary that the American forces were pulled back because they had “full confidence” in Pakistan army who were patrolling the Pak border to arrest him when he tried to cross into Pakistan. You believe that you believe anything.

6

Re: Secret Pakistan

Yes so better to close the thread or merge them I think please.

7

Re: Secret Pakistan

To demonstrate my point on the other thread please watch this clip from:

7:44 til the end.

Ok first General Athas … then it moves on to Judge Latif Afridi … 8:50 he mentions “this period” … I ask which period period? Pre-9/11 or post-9/11?

At 9:11 he says “these people have been allowed with the explicit approval of our agencies” - now during this part they move the camera away from him … perhaps when he says “our” agencies he points to the reporter and back to himself … My point being the editing makes it seem he is saying that only Pakistani agencies were in approval, but I contest that and believe he is saying that Pakistan knew and so did the West …

In other words there was NO double cross or secret play here … that part of it is manufactured.

8

Re: Secret Pakistan

These revelations are quite scary. Keeping in view Clinton's rhetorics and warnings, is it possible that some kind of revolt or taking over by military again replacing current military and political setup.

9

Re: Secret Pakistan

hahhhhahahhahahh

i watched the whole thing........... it looked like one of those Indian News Channel reports.......

its always easy....... dress someone up like a taliban/alqaeda and claim to change the identity and say whatever BS you want........

i remember, CNN's Nic Robertson does the same...........

10

Re: Secret Pakistan

how innocent , again a conspiracy ?

11

Re: Secret Pakistan

the whole world have nothing to do than conspire against poor osama, poor i.s.i. ,poor taalibaan,poor terrorists. how sad
they enact 9/11, they enact ghq attack, they enact bombay 26/11, they enact bombing of u.s. embessy, just to defame innocents al qayada, i.s.i., taliban .

12

Re: Secret Pakistan

Dear indian........ i didn't say conspiracy........... the whole documentary has a single point.......that the great US and NATO were defeated by the Taliban** ONLY **because of pakistani support for Taliban.........

PS...... you wouldn't know........ you know only this kind of 'journalism' that you have watched on your indian news channels.........

13

Re: Secret Pakistan

how clever bbc is dressing up people like taliban
not to say indian journlism who enacts bombay 26/11shows on tv
what to say about americans
only true journlists are who portray peaceful taliban and certified by nomiCA

14

Re: Secret Pakistan


just wait until uncle Sam signs deal with Taliban and you will hear journalists singing beautiful songs about same terrorists.

15

Re: Secret Pakistan

would you believe even then that B.B.C. news channels will organise six act play just to defame pakistani I.S.I. ? or any news channel will organise bombing or fake terror actors to blame some country .

16

Re: Secret Pakistan

If Indian channels can do it why can't BBC?

17

Re: Secret Pakistan

Here is something to wake you up. When saddam gassed the kurds during the war with Iran the whole western media including BBC said there was no proof that he had gassed the kurds. change the scene to 90's, saddam was no longer the blue eyed boy and lo behold there was gas footage on all western channels including BCC. question is where did the footage suddenly come from.

18

Re: Secret Pakistan

but what is the ultimate purpose of these documentaries??

19

Re: Secret Pakistan

welcome again bhaijan ,
you are great !:D

this is not a chandoo khana .

20

Re: Secret Pakistan

you may be right up to some extent, but availability or unavailability of footage is different from an agency like bbc producing fake people with costume is another thing it has never happened , any way I.S.I. has done many dubious operations ,even they have allegedly killed journlists , so the credibility of bbc is better than i.s.i.