Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

I am sorry, I may not be politically correct when I say that I am angry at all the Muslim scholars (and other Muslims) who keep touting that sea burial for OBL is a disrespect to a Muslim.

Please correct me if I am wrong but is not the same OBL who did not even show any remorse towards Muslims gotten killed in 9/11. Were those who got buried under millions of tons of rubble got a Islamic burial? Why these idiots did not say anything then?

When Al-qaeda and her illegitimate kid Taliban were decapitating Muslims in the name of US spies, and throwing their bodies in desert, was that an Islamic burial?

Just the fact that no Muslim country is ready to take his body is the proof good enough that Muslims in general disowned that SOB. To be honest, I know that nothing would change in terms of terrorism as he gave birth to many many OBLs before he died, but I am happy that we have one less OBL in this world.

*PS: my opinion should not be taken as GS’s official instance. I am just posting as a member. *

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

Agreed :k:

I, for one, couldn’t care less if they had dumped him in the bin.

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

was even a muslim.??... i wouldnt even call him a human being let alone a muslim ...plus dont you think there might be some conspiracy behind all this?? y they didnt showed his body?? and bried him sea??isn't it weird??

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

unfortunetly with or without osama which was actually US puppet ... things are gonna get more tougher for pakistanis ... 2x more suicide attacks and more turbulent times ahead for us!! :(

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

Rangoli, I heard that are are going to release his picture .. I hope they do so we put a lid on these conspiracies that it was all a fake drama.

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

Blah...I don't even believe he pulled off the 9/11 attacks by himself in the first place. A guy sitting in the caves of Tora Bora organises 5 plane hijackings in the US. Yeah *ing right. And he was living in this huge compound right next to PMA Kakul and no one in Abbottabad even wondered who lived there? Give me a *ing break, how stupid do these Americans think we are?

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

^^ I kinda fear the same Rangoli. This an end to nothing, but a beginning to a whole helluva lot!

Anyway, regarding the burial, what the reasoning behind the sea burial?

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

it should be fairly easy to see who owns the land of the huge compound. shouldn't be so hard to set the record straight on this.

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

maybe as stupid as we are.

I dont think that there is any doubt about 9/11 not being OBL's master mind. Yes there are milliions plus consipracy theories but as Occam razor's states the hypothesis with least assumption has the highest chances of being the truth.

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

That person's probably missing already and the property would be up for auction. I hear they have some pics of the dead Mr. Laden. EEEE.

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

so people do not turn his grave into some holy headquarter

Oh yes, that should be pretty straight forward

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

TLK, but they could fly his body to some remote cave area of Afghanistan or whichever country he's a citizen of, and bury it there quietly.

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

doubt a pic is going to do anything for skeptics. anyone can make a pic these days. the only way to get to reasonable people is to explain what the heck just happened - too many incredible bits and pieces in this story - the only reason i think it is likely is if they had to stage it they could have staged it some place less accessible to the media, and not involved implicating the pak army by proximity. i havent heard anyone from the pak establishment refute anything obama said.

and i really don't think he got tossed in the sea.. probably wiped off the carpet and washed down a drain or something is being called "sea burial"..

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

I don't know why he was buried at sea, but a few theories:

  1. As TLK said - no Muslim country wanted to accept his body for burial on their soil
  2. The fear that after death, some of the crazies might build shrines to him and his twisted ideologies
  3. Laash/janaazay ki bay-hurmati. The fear that the body wouldn't be treated with the dignity that any dead person is entitled to.

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

and how do we know that its not the case. A death may not be a drama but sea burial could be.

I mean they could easily bury him next to daddy long neck (Roswell dude) in area 51 and no one would know

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

they did it for the sons of Sadam .. and even that conveniently cell phone recorded video of Sadam's hanging that emerged within few hours ..
US is not going to stop without releasing his pics. That is not to prove anything but to show the world that who is the boss.
US

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

Whatever dude, **** like that does not go down without inside help. I refuse to believe the US is capable of an intelligence failure on such a massive scale.

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

It was a brilliantly planned act and OBL was no shephard, he was an evil genius. He learnt from his 1993 failure of attack on WTC and planned this one.

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

Planned what?

Re: Sea Burial, a disrespect? Really!!

Oh I was talking to Rizla about 9/11 attack.