Re: Sayings of Imam Husayn
Boy-nice, you proved once agian that you are just a boy.
There are so many questionable/controversial things in your post that I do not know where to begin.
First, I have read your post and there is nothing that contradicts my remark “Imam Hussain (r) would never have made those comments/statement”.
What grief are you ranting about? Does everyone has to show the grief the same way? You want all muslims to do mataam and take to the streets alongwith a “bhnag” induced white horse? Is that the standard of grief? Now, tell me do you do the same stuff for your deceased family memebers? If not why not? You dont love them or is it because you do not hold them as dear as the martyrs in Karbala?
Regarding you rnat about Muhammad:saw: knowing the future; we all know not to go there, however, its suffice to say that he did not. I know, I know you are going to come back with a load of ahadeeth claiming that he did. he may have known that they will have a tragic death, but I am not sure if he knew the whole details like shias claim.
Lastly, if you are so hell bent on following the “progeny” why dont you guys tell us how the immediate family members of Muhammad:saw: grieved. Start with Hazrat Ali(r), Hazrat Fatima (r)…