Sadka Jariah

[5amra]

Re: Sadka Jariah

@X2

just to add though
you can donate them to a gym or a bus station as well.
its about making a positive impact on humanity and a gift that keeps giving.
thats why we talked about education as one,

**Now as far as god being rehman and raheem..my understanding is that your account of bad deeds closes once u die, but of good deeds continues on in form of sadqa e jariya.
**
of course when my grandfather explained that to me, I came up with the statement that then someone who had a high balance of bad vs good deeds at death, can have the very opposite by the time he is judged…and if so, time plays a role and its unfair to people who were born later and thus needs to have lower weighting as time passes.

I did not get a satisfactory answer though

No, i don’t think so… I think both accounts remain active, good & bad, as STA said.
What if someone started pub or something.That will have negative impact on society & is a gunah jaria as long as it is there.
There is no doubt about this that ALLAH is rehman & raheem, ALLAH forgives anyone or everyone when HE wants, which is between the person & HIM ( haqooq ALLAH) but this (sadqa jaria & gunah jaria) is something related to haqooq alibad & it will affect the society. So if somene is doing bad or something which will have an negative impact on society is gunah jaria for that person … that person will not only get gunah of starting something bad & becoming root cause for it but also get gunah of others too who are getting affected negatively by this.