Re: roadrunner:kindly differentiate vedism and hinduism
Singh. look at this map. The Vedic civilization existed all over Pakistan, and overlapped slightly into Afghanistan (up till Helmand), and slightly into India (as far as the Western fringe of the Ganges). The Vedic civilization could be described as Pakistani, saying it was Part Punjabi is not incorrect, saying it was part Rajasthani is not incorrect (though these people have become thouroughly Dravidianized in my opinion), but to say it was “Indian” in the modern sense of borders is totally incorrect.
