Return of Hazrat Isa A.S.

[psyah]

Re: Return of Hazrat Isa A.S.

Responses in text

@Mr.Popat

ok, so Allah will **(from the text we don’t have enough information to say will but we can expect it from other hadith and the general sense and status of prophets, the correct way of reading this is "**Allah can join …") join other prophets too or just musa (as)?

Is it a rule of Allah that whichever prophet he sends to mankind will always face opposition, will be mocked at , will be faced with a lot of hardship ?
**I don’t know is it?

**Musa(as) is only what Allah meant (meant? no, we can’t say what Allah (SWT) meant … we can understand from what we see and what we see is that Musa (AS) is being addressed in the second person … sometimes they can be interpolated to encompass others in the general sense, but that would not be binding on others) in the hadith.

Abraham is only what Allah meant when he joined him with a prophet prior to him (noah as). (**No this is a different argument to the one about Musa (AS). This is an argument regarding possibility, Ibrahim (AS) lived and died before those prophets.) **Abraham is the only one whose neither Jew nor christian, though, same cannot be said about Noah, (**no this is false reasoning … I didn’t say that … **) since Allah did not meantion him in that verse(he can be a jew or christian) (No … because the reason was given why Ibrahim (AS) can’t be it’s because he lived and died before them) . Jesus on the other hand is an exception no matter what !. Jesus will be grouped with Moses as well as with the shariyah of Muhammad(pbuh).

(**It is because Isa (AS) lived before Muhammad (SAW) and will live after him too - that is why there is an exception for Isa (AS).

**Ok. Thank you

You are welcome!