Return of Hazrat Isa A.S.

[Mr.Popat]

Re: Return of Hazrat Isa A.S.

@kchughtai

The concept of Jesus (as) living up in the heavens and his return actually supports the idea of him (as) being a deity. Here is how:

1. At the time of danger, Allah helped the messengers keeping them in this world. Examples of Mosa (as), Yousaf (as), Ibrahim (as) and our holy prophet (pbuh) are before us. The uniqueness that is attributed to Isa (as) is that he (as) was taken to heavens when his life was in danger.
2. As per Quran, as we become old, we get weaker but the rule that is applicable to all including all messengers is not applicable to Isa (as) as he is still young even after passage of 2000+ years. He is unique in this way. Pls refer to 36:68 i.e., “And him whom We grant long life — We revert him to a weak* condition of *creation. Will they not then understand?”
3. He will descend from the heavens with angels. He is unique in this way. No other prophet came to the world in this way.
4. No other prophet came to this world for the 2[SUP]nd[/SUP] time. He is unique in this way.
5. When Christians presented the argument of divinity of Jesus (as) as his birth was fatherless, example of Adam (as) was put forward to refute their claim of this extra-ordinary uniqueness. If his ascent and future descent is not contested and that was the belief of the holy prophet (pbuh) then Isa (as) is unique in this way.

I do not see any point above as weak arguments.

I’m constantly reading this thread but not writing anything. I’ve had a long debate with psyah before if he remembers, and that thread is still there somewhere.

anyway, i really would like to get a response from anyone to mr. kchughtai’s points