Return of Hazrat Isa A.S.

[psyah]

Re: Return of Hazrat Isa A.S.

@kchughtai

^
First of all, I couldn’t understand the connection that you want to make between the quoted verse and the hadith. Secondly, why are you presenting a verse that doesn’t stand a chance to consolidate your stance by your own standards?

1. Different people have interpreted it differently. For some people ‘INNA HU’ pertains to Quran and for others, it pertains to Isa (as).
2. ‘SAA-AA’ may point to any time/moment as per literal meanings you are so much in love with, not necessarily to ‘Judgment day’.

To me, it pertains to Quran as it is the final code of life from Allah and valid till the Day of Judgment and it contains signs of judgment day.
As per the hadith you have mentioned, the sign of the Hour should be the holy prophet (pbuh) and the message he brought. ‘Don’t disbelieve in it and follow me. This is the right path’ also point in that direction.

Peace kchughtai

Who says that this innahu refers to Qur’an? Please show me and is this difference of opinion one where there is no ‘ijma’.