Respect of Women

[Arleitter]

Re: Respect of Women

@The_Player

Irrelevant point. Yes, Manusmriti laid out the basis of the caste system, but it was based more on the work done by people and not the way it is followed today. As for the reason why caste system has not been abolished, it has more to do with the so-called lower castes getting huge benefits from reservations and not willing to let go of it.

For all the rhetoric, you have not been able to explain how Manusmriti is similar to the concept of Sharia in Islam, which was the original point of this debate.

I am not qualified to speak on other religions, so lets just stick to Hinduism here. Advaita Vedanta is the fundamental belief of Hinduism. Can you deny the concepts laid out there ?

You are calling the biggest dimension as irrelevant. Caste system has been followed in India and in other parts for centuries and this is yielded from Manusmriti .It is not followed in these modern times as it had been in the earier perids simply because India is a country that got ravaged by external incursions which became a great detrimental factor in fading such great eras like that of vedic times.Moreover India is a nation that has become a roost for diverse religions and cultures post vedic era and it has become impossible/difficult to employ the code and conduct of Manusmriti and other scripts. Simple.

Ofcourse Mansumriti is like Shariat because Manusmriti clearly underlines the social objectives and the various punishments need to be delivered for social rules and laws violations.

If you can not comment about other religions,how will you engage in a debate here?Why did you force our other members in to discussion here? I am asking you one simple question.If you are a follower of Advaita ,you should be able to answer my question that’s if all god/goddess forms in this world are mythical.If you can single out goddess Durga and say that she is a a mythical form ,then according to you all other god /goddess forms should be mythical,given that you are a follower of Advaita .Why are you not able to comment on it?