Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ? [Merged]

Sad if true…I wonder how wide spread cases like this are?

By MERAIAH FOLEY

Associated Press Writer

SYDNEY, Australia (AP) - The U.S. military said Wednesday it was investigating a report carried on an Australian television network that claimed American soldiers in Afghanistan burned the bodies of two Taliban fighters and then used the action to taunt other Islamic militants.

The SBS television network broadcast video footage that purportedly showed U.S. soldiers burning the bodies of the suspected Taliban fighters in the hills outside the southern village of Gonbaz, near the former Taliban stronghold of Kandahar.

The network said the footage was taken by a freelance journalist, Stephen Dupont, who told The Associated Press he was embedded with the 173rd Airborne Brigade of the U.S. Army earlier this month. Dupont said the burnings happened on Oct. 1.

In the footage, which was seen by the AP, two soldiers who spoke with American accents later read taunting messages that the SBS said were broadcast to the village, which was believed to be harboring Taliban soldiers.

SBS said the soldiers were part of a U.S. Army psychological operations unit

The U.S. military said the Army Criminal Investigation Division had opened an investigation into alleged misconduct that included ``the burning of dead enemy combatant bodies under inappropriate circumstances.‘’

``This command takes all allegations of misconduct or inappropriate behavior seriously and has directed an investigation into circumstances surrounding this allegation,‘’ Maj. Gen. Jason Kamiya said in a statement the U.S. base in Bagram, Afghanistan.

Shortly after the bodies were burned, another group of soldiers allegedly sent taunting messages about the act to the nearby village, according to a transcript of the program.

``Taliban, you are all cowardly dogs. You allowed your fighters to be laid down facing west and burned. You are too scared to come down and retrieve their bodies,‘’ said one message read by a soldier, according to the transcript.

The footage did not show the messages being broadcast, though it did show some military vehicles were fitted with speakers and playing loud music.

Dupont told the AP the messages had been broadcast in the local dialect but were translated into English for him by members of the Army psychological operations unit.

He declined to provide further information, however, saying his agent was now handling all queries about the footage.

Cremation of bodies is not part of Islamic tradition, which calls for remains to be washed, prayed over, wrapped in white cloth and buried within 24 hours.

Dupont said the soldiers who burned the bodies said they did so for hygiene reasons. However, Dupont said the incendiary messages later broadcast by the U.S. army psychological operations unit indicated they were aware that the cremation would be perceived as a desecration.

They used that as a psychological warfare, I guess you'd call it. They used the fact that the Taliban were burned facing west (toward Mecca),'' Dupont told SBS. They deliberately wanted to incite that much anger from the Taliban so the Taliban could attack them … . That’s the only way they can find them.‘’

Ameer Ali, the head of the Australian Federation of Islamic Councils, said burning a body would be considered a desecration in the Islamic faith.

The SBS report suggested the deliberate burning of bodies could violate the Geneva Conventions governing the treatment of enemy remains in wartime. Under the Geneva Conventions, soldiers must ensure that the ``dead are honorably interred, if possible according to the rites of the religion to which they belonged.‘’

Furthermore, the rules state that bodies should not be cremated, ``except for imperative reasons of hygiene or for motives based on the religion of the deceased.‘’


Associated Press Reporter Mike Corder in Sydney contributed to this report.

Guardian

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

Everything is fair in love and war Right?

Talibans burned them and they are burning talibans. Its wrong muslims bodies are being burned but i got a question. After killing so many innocent lives and taking a life of a child and making them in to a terrorist - Are you still a muslim? After beating your wife or leaving her are you stilla muslim? after marketing suicide bombing among other muslims are you still a muslim?

Its easy to point finger on others but dont forget three of them are facing you.

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

^
all that is true and well, only after u prove it to everyone that they really were talibans or their members?

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

huh....these callous beast americans and northern alliance killed 10,000 taliban and paki people in containers.....but no body shouted....they introduced the term "dead dance" which is made me believe tht americans soldiers r beasts and they r "*******s"....

nia khan,such threads r not for ur kind...so kindly keep urself away from such threads beacu have to believe wht media tells

Americans burning Taliban footmen

found very diturbing BBC NEWS | South Asia | US probe into 'Taleban burnings'

Re: Americans burning Taliban footmen

Now where is the GS peeps that try to make everything that reflects negatively on US military a false propaganda effort.

I wont mention names but we all know who they are.

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

for Allah’s sake atleast have some iman during ramadhan. the devils are chained so it must be your inner kufr that is talking now. defend the honor of muslims from the crusading army or if you cant do that then dont talk.

Re: Americans burning Taliban footmen

hmm...they r contacting pentagon so they can tell them "any sensible reason" to call the video fake....i hope american soldiers will burn in fire...these americans r mental case
and we can understand y these american soldiers behave like tht...afterall,,many of them dont have fathers...,

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

what's the big deal, they're dead? It's a bit twisted, but I don't really have a problem with it.

As marytyrs, I'm sure they don't care either. Their souls are too busy gettin down-in-dirty with 6 dozen hotties, right?

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

are you a necrophiliac or something? it’s part of the professional code of honour of good soldiers not to mutilate or desecrate the bodies of enemy slain. it just lends credence to the perception around the world that american soldiers are trained to be savages and not the “men of honour” of Hollywood legend.

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

No Americans are supposed to fight according to the geneva conventions and muslims if they claim to be islamic soldiers according to the rules of Islam.
But we should also condemn the dragging and hanging of the burnt corpses of american soldiers whether in falluja or somalia

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

some people need to re-familiarize themselves with what a war is.

PC culture isn't part of war.

of ALL people on earth, muslims should know that.

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

what's PC culture

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

Wondering if the news is true (shown on an australian tv???), taliban's wahabi extremism is to blame for what is happening to Afghanistan right now!

I mean this is wrong but look at the attitudes of taliban and how they have not many friends in their own strongholds to fight America!

Sad state of affairs in muslim world!

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

are you the newest bhangee to visit gupland?

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

Thank you for telling me that you are hereby forfeiting your rights to indignant whining about dead soldiers being dragged through the streets of mogadishu.

Did you cry? I know i cringed.

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ?

^
There is a big difference. Cremation is very common in the states while dragging dead bodies in the streets is not common anywhere. If this was done for health reasons then it's not really an issue.

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ? [Merged]

that's a good point, but it's not like groups of people (including kids) were savagely jumping on, kicking and then stringing up their bodies for display. I see a difference, albeit perhaps not a major one. All's fair I guess.

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ? [Merged]

Let's not split hairs as to what constitutes desecration. Moral relativism is at play here, UTD.

Burning bodies in islamic custom facing West is an act of desecration; so is stringing a dead body and dragging it through the street.

Afterall, we are there to win the hearts and minds, aren't we?

Re: Report: U.S. Troops Burned Taliban Bodies ? [Merged]

From what I understand that the bodies were originally burned for hygienic reasons and then a propaganda tape was made with the footage. If the bodies were burned to insult Muslim customs then punishments need to be handed down and that behavior can't be tolerated.