You are perfectly right to criticise generalisations and attack that but why personally attack someone’s personal qualities? how does that contribute to discussion?Also, as an Indian Muslim KKF does not believe in caste system and was just talking of his family in India. Discussion of rape and the caste system really does not fit this. Neither of our countries are great at women’s safety so i don’t think it is a point of comparison. The only similarity with PCG is the generalising part but apart from that he still keeps in contact with his relatives.