Re: Refuting wrong beliefs of a liar
his opinion was quiet specific, he gave a lot of details which were ‘exactly’ the same as the Mushrikin. It is very unlikely that he was talking about inadvertent shirk because the area he was talking regarding is something which is well known, and vouched for by the Muslims [we’re not worthy, stepping stones, running around for waseela but not always going direct to Allah The All-Knowing]. so what we are talking about cant be inadvertent because it is deliberate.
It is deliberate [but not shirk]
Im not encouraging you to talk on such topic at all, rather go make tauba [repent] for the comments you made the last time you talked in one of these topics [menk thread]! This would be correcting you
This topic is ‘showing’ you the narrow minded, non sunni, potentially non Muslim beliefs of yasir qadhi. It is not an invitation to argue, unless you want to.