Re: references for ijma
[QUOTE]
Dont get emotional, can you get me some evidence regarding this, i would be really grateful. I am talking about meeting between Malik and Hanifa and the meeting between shafi and ahmed.
[/QUOTE]
There are many incidents that I have read and also heard in many speeches and whenever I get these links, I shall PM you. No one has deny that.
[QUOTE]
Really, can you tell me since when Imam Abu Hanifa started taking interest in Islam, and can you come across any one hadeeth which supporst your point.
[/QUOTE]
He was a business man and once he was passing by a great scholar of Kufa, who mistook Imam Abu Hanfi for 1 of his students. Later on he told Imam Abu Hanifa. that he should start studying Fiqh under him. So thats how it all started.
[QUOTE]
Whose taqleed did mujtahid do, how cna you say they did not do taqleed they did taqleed
[/QUOTE]
Mujtahids dont do taqleed, they can derive their own conclusions from Quran and Sunnah.
[QUOTE]
Can you support your evidence from Noorul Anwar and support your point regarding Ameen. Well if this is the case please do visit madrasas and ask them can we say ameen loudly.
Get me the evidence of Imam Hanifa and Imam Shafi, again would be grateful thanks.
[/QUOTE]
Why would I visit a madrassa when I alrady know the position of all 4 madhabs on this issue. I know scholars of different madhabs and this is their position. Its all about which is more superior. You said it was biddah accorindg to Imam Shafi so shouldnt the proof of burden be on you? But I would highly recommed you to read this book called fiqh al Iman by Mufti Abdur Rahman ibn Yusuf on all these issues. So many of your questions will be answered.
[QUOTE]
Sahaba differed fine, but you are telling on fiqhi issues right what can be those fiqhi issues can you throw some light on it.
[/QUOTE]
These same issues like saying Ameen loud or slowly, where to put hands in Salat, should they put on above navel or below. Also the matter on rafal yadeen etc etc.
[QUOTE]
So you mean to say some sahabas said it in there heart and some said it softly claiming hte Haddeeth of Prophet in Bukhari wrong. Well go ah ead i am waiting for your evidences.
[/QUOTE]
Again what hadees you are talking about? That says say ameen with the angels? Thats the hadees Hanafis use because can you hear the angels say ameen? No oyu cant, so same way we say it slowly. There are many hadees on this issue, and you just took 1 hadees and reached your own conclusion.