Re: Quranist rise and end of Sunni/Shia sect
[QUOTE]
First the Quran never talked about any battles between the prophet and Jews or Christians. All the battles in the Quran are with the pagans
[/QUOTE]
but we know that the Propehet fought against and punished jewish tribes. How do u explain that or due doubt the historical accuracy of khaibar, khandaq and banu quraizah incident.
[QUOTE]
The Quran does not have a concept of Dhimmis and taxes and a state.
[/QUOTE]
Here we have a fundamental difference of opinion
I think that islam without a state is an orphan, helpless and at mercy of exploitation.
Foundation of islamic state governed by islamic rules and which dispenses justice for all muslim and nonmuslim is the natural outcome of the "enjoin good and forbid evil " principle in islam.