Quota system-is it justified: split from Karachi blood bath

[Iconoclast]

@Khan15

Icon Jat Sahib,

Jinnah is federal institution. Read there website. And 20% of the qouta is from Punjab. That’s a fact.

JPMC Home

As Saleem has said, its an hospital, and not a medical college.

According to the 1973 constitution, quota was only instituted for 10 years. Then that Badmash Zia extended it, and used to it to create the MQM.

The beneficiaries of the quota are not the deprived, but a creamy layer from cities in the Punjab. If it realy helped the deprived, then no one would have any objections.

Khan lakhnawi sahib

From your intital post it wasnt clearwhether you are talkign about Jinnah Medical and Dental College seats for medical students (were there is no qouta for Punjabis) or the jobs in federal hospital.

However, federak qouta system works bothways, that is in federal institutions in Punjab you also get a qouta of 7.6%, apply there.

Secondly, you are in power in Sindh with PPP, why haven’t you scrapped the qouta so far? Bcoz Sindhis will not allow it. I would tend to agree that it does help the deprived as much as it should mainly bcoz of abuse of system. Its teh rich people residing in large cities but of rural background like Sindhis in urban areas who on basis of domicile will get seats.

And for your info qouta in federal jobs was not started by Bhutto in 1973, but by Liaqat Ali Khan for migrants. Thats why upians and cpians continued to come to Pakistan till late 1950s to get jobs.