Re: QUESTIONS TO A SHIA
AOA!
My Sunni and Shia brothers, I AM SHIA and inshAllaha can answer all the questions from Quran, Hadith, and Sceince/logic.
but
Please request u all to be pateint and listen to each other and try to learn not to fight.
one of my brother has noted few staements from one of the book from a renowned sgia scholar ( naubakhti) and my brother says this and that.
So my brother the simplest answer to that ( can go with several answers but I beleive we are here to learn and therefore only glimpse would be more than enough and if u need more than we can look into it from other angles), so the simplest answer is:
"NONE OF THE BOOKS WRITTEN BY NOBAKHTI IS/ARE SAHIH OR KITAB AFTER BAARI"
we shia has no book from any one as SAHIH therefore simple we shia beleive that a writer can have an error and can be looked at, challenged, argued and come up with an alternative as long as in the light of Quran and Hadith (of course akal as without akal every thing is use less)
Forget about Nobakhti, even book of Ahadith in shia school of thought are open to debat.
All the above discussion is based on certain realities.
1)man is error prone not masoom
2)every one is biased or inclined towards some thing
3) shia writers of the books in almost every book PESH LAFZ or MUKADMAA defines the qulaity
4) shia and shia scholars keep books open to debated and filtered out
wasalam