Re: QUESTIONS TO A SHIA
And status of this shia scholar **nobakhti **is so **graet **that some other shia scholars write that;
1.Nobakhthi was a great scholar of ilm-e-kalam, philosophy and true shia believer....(Fahrish-ut-tussi pg.98 india ..1835)
2.Nobakhti was a great scholar of shia*.(alfaharist -al- najjashi pg.47 india 1317 hijri)*
3. nobakhi was great ilme kalam scholar ..the greats of shia religion and philosohy*....(Majalis-ul-momineen by Noor-allah-tustri pg.177 iran)*
and this same man , **nobakhti **writes in his book:
"""""""ibne saba **was a man who started **curse **on abu bakr, umar and usman(ra) and he said that ali(ra) ordered him to do this...when the news reached to ali(ra)...ali(ra) ordered him to arrest and when he brought to ali(ra) he accepted his crime .Ali(ra) instantly ordered that to kill ibne saba ...but the army men of ali(ra) which were mostly **iraqis and kufis started **shouting how can you kill a lover of ahle-bait ..so ali(ra) was **compelled **to expell ibne saba to **madyan...a city which is now about 40 km. of present day baghdad*.....(Farq-s-shia by Nobakhti)*