Re: Question regarding fasting on 12th rabiu-awal
1.false...no where is written only quranic hadees is hadees only...first time i am listening from u that qul is a hadees...no other....
2.effect definitely of these dynasties...but it is totally ridiculous to say that they are totally wrong...just like ideality is nature of angel and prophet only...but practically you can achieve 99 % or more...due o 1 or less than 1 % error as by human nature..is it normal to negate 99 % correct..you have full full preperation ..even out of thousands only1 or 2 get 100 out of 100 in maths...not to speak of physics and chemistry...so the student acheiving 98 % is not "acceptable" as a genius because he loses 2 marks...according to yoour hypothesis...what is this....
3.totally wrong ..abdullah ibne amr bin al'as(ra) wrote ahadees in front of prophet(pbuh) and checked by prophet(pbuh) ...sahifa-sadiqa..i think..similarly abu uraira (ra) also did the same thing...propht(pbyh) sent some details of zakat and sadqa not in quran in the written form to mauz bin jabal ansari in sana(yeman) .....and various other texts.....