Question from Muslims who believe

[psyah]

Re: Question from Muslims who believe

@kchughtai

The earth is made into existence and is still in transient state. That’s right but your analogy of a movie is pretty flawed one. Is this the best example you could come up with? Creation and destruction of the whole universe in every moment…. Where did you get this idea. Pls substantiate it. No whimsical ideas please.

Let me clarify a bit. Kun is not merely the initiator it encompasses the whole creation process. What I wanted to say is that Kun didn’t bring certain desired goal instantly although a seed was sown. It started happening in a guided or measured way and that is what is evident. Yes,Allah creates things that were non-existent before and from nothing but it is His design to make things happen the way they are. Nothing is outside the bounds of His power. When He said ‘kun’ in case of Isa(as), his being came into existence instantly in a very basic form and it took its usual course. He could have sent messengers born out of thin air instantly in adult age, He could have created and perfected earth and heavens in a nano-second but if it didn’t happen that way doesn’t depict weakness on His part. It only shows that He is the king of heavens and earth and it is His will and design that prevails and no one else’s

Please explain why it is a flawed analogy?

Allah (SWT) is The Sustainer … Nothing can exist or develop, grow or change except that it happens through Allah (SWT).

Also, to maximise how we understand the Power of Allah (SWT) - He can Create the whole Universe through Kun … This means “all of what we see” CAN instantly come in to place. The fact that it did not come in to place exactly how we see it - is not less amazing - because each moment is expressly from the Kun. It is not enough to assume that only the changes are being managed by Allah (SWT) - even the ongoing constancy of the existence of things is being managed by Allah (SWT).