Re: Question for all
Same way according to Shias, Hazrat Abu Talib died on Islam where as Bibi Ayesha died on disbelief.
In Musnad Ahmed Hanbal, it is mentoined that Bibi Ayehsa had named Uthman as Nathal, who should be killed and Murtakib-e-kufr. If Bibi is regarded as siidiqa then we will have to accept what she called Uthman.
Now if I take word of Bibi Ayesha and refer to Uthamn as Kafir all hell will break loose, but its ok to call Hazrat Abu Talib kafir, even though shias don’t beleive that.
I can go on an and elaborate on this hadeeth, but I don’t want to start another debate, I would prefer if people can stick to the issue I had orignaly raised. Which was about soura thereems ayat # 5