Purging GS of Extremists

[Sara516]

Re: Purging GS of Extremists

@PyariCgudia

ultra liberals, the hadith rejectors

Can someone explain to the drunk guy here that these are not extremist stances? Since they don’t involve propagating violence to prove their point, necessarily?

Now yes, if you’ve got someone who rejects hadith, and then says “oh you don’t reject hadith? Okay fine - i"m gonna kill you, or you should be murdered” would be extremist, yes.

But how many people who reject hadith actually going around and saying that?

Its usually people who think that hadith should be forced down people’s throats by State force that are of the opinion anyone who disobeys the inherently self-contradicting sets of hadith should be killed.

I don’t know what is a murtadeen, so I can’t comment unless you decide to come off your high horse and provide me an english translation for the word.

So rejecting something that is in the Quran, doubting the validity of hte Prophet, saying most hadith are worthless doesn’t seem xtreme to you?