PTI's performance in Karachi

KARACHI: The results announced by the Election Commission of Pakistan on Monday show that the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf has emerged as an important party in Karachi, polling over 50,000 votes in at least one National Assembly constituency.
In NA-245, North Nazimabad, a stronghold of the Muttahida Quami Movement, Riaz Haider obtained about 54,000 votes against Muttahida Qaumi Movement candidate Rehan Hashmi, who polled a little over 100,000.
Similarly, in NA-246, Federal B Area, another locality where the MQM has enjoyed a somewhat unrivalled monopoly, Amir Sharjeel of the PTI polled about 32,000 votes, whereas his heavyweight MQM opponent Nabeel Gabol, former PPP stalwart, obtained 139,386 votes.
In NA-243, another MQM dominated area comprising North Karachi and New Karachi, Zahid Hussain Hashmi of the PTI got about 30,000 votes while the MQM contestant got 192,678 votes.
Rashid Siddiqui of the PTI in NA-247 (Liaquatabad) got over 35,000 votes and NA-251 (Mehmoodabad) contestant of the PTI Raja Azhar polled nearly 39,000 votes.
PTI chief Imran Khan did not address any rally in his electioneering campaign in Karachi. The one major rally he had addressed here was in December 2011. Yet looking at the numbers one can easily deduce that the PTI has built a significant voter base in Karachi.
Mohammed Hanif, Karachi-based journalist and novelist, explains the development as: “Karachi would be a natural kind of PTI constituency. Its campaign was targeted at the urban masses who are agitated and Karachi is filled with such kind of people. Also when we talk about the Pakistan Peoples Party’s incumbency factor then the same reason can be applied to the MQM. It has been in Karachi for a long time, having been in power since Musharraf’s days. People want to try someone new hence these numbers are not surprising.”
Moreover, the PTI polled vote figures are equally impressive in provincial constituencies. In PS-103 (Karachi 15), PTI candidates Zareena Sarwar, Siddiqullah of PS-104 (Karachi-16) and Abid Jilani of PS-120 (Karachi-32) obtained over 17,000 votes. Then there were three other PTI contestants who polled more than 20,000 votes — Muhammad Jawed Jillani of PS-105, Ataullah Khan PS-119 and Erum Butt PS-116. Arsalan Ghumman put up a good fight at PS-118 where he scored 31,802 votes against the MQM candidate, who obtained 56,145 votes.
As to how the MQM should look at these numbers, Mr Hanif says: “I hope the MQM realises that this is a healthy development and that voting for another candidate is good. They need to rethink their strategy rather than having an undue reaction to new realities which is not going to help them in the long run.”
He, however, cautions the first-time PTI voters: “PTI supporters need to realise that just because you stand in line for six hours and vote and your candidate loses does not mean you have to be self-righteous. First-time PTI voters need to realise that someone has to lose and this is what happens in elections.”
When Wasay Jaleel, an MQM leader, was asked by Dawn whether the party had noticed the phenomenon of the PTI bagging significant numbers of votes in its strongholds, he says: “Yes, we did notice it and we attribute this to the 10-party alliance that voted against us. We did meet some youngsters in Gulshan-i-Iqbal and Nazimabad who voted for the PTI but that’s because they are popular with the youth. The MQM sees other political parties as good competition and we do realise that they are other representatives of the people in the city but the 10-party anti-MQM alliance with boycott by the Jamaat-i-Islami worked in favour of the PTI.”

http://beta.dawn.com/news/1011180/results-show-pti-has-vote-bank-in-mqm-strongholds

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

The above figures shows that PTI was a clear cut winner from Karachi if MQM did not rig the elections.

Even from Altaf's own area, they took an amazing 32,000 votes.

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

Any reason for this conclusion?

Are there any rigging evidence from NA-246 (Altaf's own area)?

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

Everyone knows how they filled in the boxes later on. Voters turnover was never more than 30%. I know hardly anyone going to vote from my mohallah in 2008 but they won with vast majority.

Even from Liaqatabad they got more than 30,000 votes and these are votes people polled in the morning.

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

I mean are there any concrete evidence to be presented in courts of law to prove rigging in these strongholds of MQM? If there was that much rigging and compulsion, how PTI got 32,000 votes from 90's constituency as MQM leaders believe that they got 85% of city's mandate and if they wanted they have proved it through rigging or whatever sources.

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

If free and fair elections happen in Karachi PTI can win atleast 4 5 seats easily

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

Here is an unbiased opinion:

PTI did receive many votes from Muttahida core. Especially from youngsters. Like I said, there are some PTI voters in my own family.

BUT to suggest that PTI would have won had there been no rigging is totally unfair. This view is based on assumption that Muttahida forces everyone to vote for it.
I think there are instances that rigging takes place at some scale, and there is sometimes some coercion too. But none of this is enough for MQM to win seats it should lose.
Such rigging takes place every where in the country.

There is genuine support for MQM in the city. However, with the passage of time, and with PTI doing positively in other people's eyes; things might change against MQM.

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

Reason for Karachiites voting for PTI:

Just like PMLN and PPP voters, the MQM voters also want to see some change. Also, some are fundamentally MQM voters but disapprove some of its policies. So they want to vote different to teach MQM a lesson that they should not take people for granted.

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

I disagree. The fact they rigged to this silly levels which they did was that they were afraid he would win, otherwise why go to extreme lengths if even without rigging PTI would not win?

Re: PTI’s performance in Karachi

PTI bags first Sindh Assembly seat

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

Altaf is now sick knowing the fact that PTI is becoming a majority party in Karachi now

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

PTI must penetrate in Karachi and also provide people of interior Sindh with alternatives. Instead of taking on MQM goons directly, it should start ralizing its presence in Karachi in a calculated and compose manner.

Re: PTI’s performance in Karachi

which areas this constituency covers?

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

I think its not far fetched to say that the desperate rigging scale in the metro cities of Karachi and Lahore mean that in reality, these cities dont belong to MQM and PML-N any more.

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

PS-43 is Karachi V.

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

Its PS-93 and it covers areas of SITE Karachi, means that seat might have been won by ANP in last elections

Re: PTI’s performance in Karachi

^ Correct, it’s PS-93 :k:

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

Karachi_Post (@Karachi_Post) tweeted at 11:49pm - 14 May 13:

Fact- Fair elections in #Karachi would have seen #PTI winning at least 5 seats #Pakistan #Pakvotes #MQM

Re: PTI's performance in Karachi

ye kia hai?

Re: PTI’s performance in Karachi

NA-250: MQM rejects re-polling on 43 stations