Provincial autonomy and concurrent lists

[Blitzkrieg]

Re: Provincial autonomy and concurrent lists

@ganguly

The two main points that all the people I talked with keep coming back to are the issues of provincial autonomy and giving back ministries like health, education, and finance to the provinces and doing away with the wasteful dual handling of these ministries.

---

Man i thought that’s what federalism means , that’s how we have it India other than defence foreign affaris comunication centre doesn’t control anything in state… This kind of federal control in a country whose founder Jinnah was hell bent on demanding for total autonomy in every affairs for accepting to stay in indian federation sounds ludicrous..

Bhindi, don’t come here and bull****!

Jinnah was a very pro-indian federation person and you go ask your indian analysts like Paraful Bidwai among others who will tell you that it was wrong of Nehru and Sardar Patel to not allow provincial autonomy back then (fully centralized indian administration they wanted which showed up when they tried to impose one language in the country as indians say).

Had they agreed to the demands of Jinnah about more autonomy for E. and W. Pakistan (then india) then Partition wouldn’t happen!

But an RSS hate monger like you wouldn’t understand, would it?