Prophet Mohammed nine year old wife

Re: Prophet Mohammed nine year old wife

Peace Mughal1

For the first time in my life I read one of your responses completely from beginning to end. The first part sounds good … The second part is that you are nearly making a point but you stop …

I think your contention is regarding the hadith that we have today - you say they are in some way fabricated or changed by the deceivers.

Well we can test theory …

All we need to do is check to see if these ahadith have been reciprocated/mirrored by others … do they appear in other chains outside this partciluar contentious chain?

We have to look for evidence of exactly the same hadith being narrated with a different age … that will show at some point a difference of stated age had crept in during a transmission.

We have all the tools to check and ratify the transmission - it is not enough to say “It sounds wrong to my standards therefore it is wrong” … If it sounds wrong … then investigate … don’t just throw it out.