khoji
June 13, 2013, 5:12pm
93
Re: Praying on dargahs & shrines
That is one nice post, Saleem. Especially liked the bold parts.
Well, I appreciate your ignorance of Islam and Islamic teaching. But as you wrote that … agar nahi pata tou chup rahna chahiyea … you should do that, because your comments could easily take you to fire.
If you are so much about asking direct from Allah … than why you do not ask directly from Allah a book of guidance ?
Why you are quoting Quran as book of Allah**, Quran that Allah did not sent to you**, but it is word of prophet (SAW) that this book is from Allah?
Have you got any guarantee that Quran is word of Allah … other than belief that Prophet (SAW) was prophet of Allah and that Allah used Prophet (SAW) as Waseela for us to get guidance from Allah in form of Quran and other practices that Allah wants? … I do not think that you were even born when Prophet (SAW) was in this world, so you cannot even say that this book (Quran) was sent to Muslims by Allah using Prophet (SAW) as waseela, as that knowledge is also through waseela of peoples who were between us and Prophet (SAW).
So … if you do not believe on Waseela, then you should leave Islam … the religion that Allah sent through Prophet (SAW) and follow whatever ‘religion’ you get directly from Alalh … (hint: be atheist if you do not get direct guidance from Allah … as that is what you should be with your belief).
I do not think you ever read Quran or you have knowledge of Islam … to say that Prophets are not born prophets, and that Prophet (SAW) was became Muslim when Allah choose him and send Jabrael (AS) to him in cave ‘hira’. … but then, I should not argue with you because I am pretty sure that since you do not believe on Waseela, how can you believe on Quran anyhow as that book came to Muslims (only Muslims) through Waseela of Prophet (SAW).
Note: For Muslims… we should know that prophets are born prophets and are not chosen by Allah from pious of the time to be prophet. Actually, as far as Prophet (SAW) is concerned, his (SAW) expected arrival to this world as prophet was even mentioned in all past books. Allah even named him in earlier scriptures from Allah. The age prophet (AS) declare their prophet-hood is nothing to do with them being prophet before that age or not, as they are always prophet. For instance, from Quran we know that Musa (AS) and ISA (AS) were prophets at birth, though we also know that both declared their prophet-hood at much later age. Allah mentioned in Quran that he sent prophets in every nation … not that he choose a prophet in every nation.