PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

So bilawal wannabe “national leader” believes that federation is so weak that a budget can pose threat to it. Btw the Punjabistan term used by PPP is on the mainstream media and now more number of people have access to internet. I hope people read it and realize to put an absolute end to PPP’s politics in Punjab.

PPP rejects ‘Punjabistan-centric’ budget - Pakistan - DAWN.COM

ISLAMABAD: The Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) has been very vocal in its criticism of the federal budget, and while the party chief described the budget as a tool to strengthen ‘Punjabistan’, the economic managers of his party foresaw a Greece-like situation developing in Pakistan.

“Seems this budget has been designed to break the federation. We reject one unit budget for Punjab*istan,” PPP chairperson Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari tweeted on Tuesday.

While he may not have been able to pack too much nuance into 140 characters, his party’s financial wizards feared that Pakistan could become the next Greece in ten years if the current government continued its figure-fudging, kept burdening the exchequer with heavy loans, remained biased towards Punjab and kept encroaching on the rights of provinces.

Speaking at a press conference at Sindh House on Tuesday, Senator Saleem Mandviwalla and the PPP economic team said the budget for 2016-17 reflected the attitude of the centre threatening the federation.

He decried the government’s bias towards Punjab, saying that more than Rs600 billion in PSDP projects were being allocated to one province only, asking, “what do you expect the smaller provinces to do, eat the air?”

The economy was heading for a disaster because it was based on false and incorrect information, he alleged. “Recently, the UN resident director asked me ‘When will you stop this figure fudging?’ His statement was not directed towards me, but the whole parliament,” Senator Mandviwalla said.

He said that no policy could be successful without sound foundations and a realistic picture.

He also said the budget was designed deliberately to pose a threat to the federation, as there were several encroachments on the rights of the provinces.

“Earlier, the federal government tried to take the right of collecting GST on services from the provinces, but this time they have tried to snatch the right to collect property tax,” he said.

Both he and former petroleum minister Syed Naveed Qamar called the budget ‘direction-less’, saying it seemed to have no economic vision, long-term policy goals or strategies to improve tax compliance, reduce tax evasion and provide relief to honest taxpayers.

“There is a need to present the true picture of the situation; they are building the PSDP on loans, even salaries are being given from loans,” Senator Mandviwalla added.

Mr Qamar claimed that the figure-fudging and heavy borrowing was a targeted policy of the finance minister to impress the IMF. “His only target is to show the IMF good numbers.”

He said that Mr Dar was so obsessed with numbers that he resorted to criticising the agriculture sector for spoiling their overall numbers. “He should have shown concern about the farmers, not the figures that his failed economy could not achieve,” he said, adding that the IMF was fully controlling the Pakistani economy now.

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

Yesterday Qamar Zaman Kaira also spoke against this statement of BBZ... whatever is left of PPP in Punjab main join PTI & PMLN

And yes BBZ is going to bury PPP in Garhi Khuda Bakhsh..

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

I think, from the responses to his visits to Kashmir, bahwalpur and rahim yar khan, he realized that PPP can do nothing in other provinces so lets tighten grip on rural sindh votes at least.

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

Bhaio ,
what ever is given as a written speech . He made a ratta and vomit during the jalsa... Do u think he knows what he is saying . What are the consequences of using word Punjabistan by a " charron sobon i zanjeer " to PPP- pubjab.

PPP - punjab can feel how some of MQM rabta committee members feel after some stupid speech of AH.

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

^^^

Now likes if Qamar Zaman, Aitzaz Ahsan,& Khursheed shah shall be talking of "out-of-context" or "with-the-context" and shall be clearing it untill next blunder or may be calling Zardari Senior and ask him to shut him down....

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

THIS IS NOT STORY OF THIS BUDGET , ALMOST PAKISTAN'S HISTORY IS HISTORY OF LOOTING OF TAKHT e LAHORE & PUNJABI ESTABLISHMENT .

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

You must be proud of your only "hope" on giving such statements, right?
Btw, what happened to PPP's campaigns in Kashmir and southern punjab?

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

Please name 5 influentional politicians from Lahore... from 1947 till 2016...

Thanks

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

In another article, following joke is mentioned :smiley:
Replying to a question, Sharmila Farooqi said the PPP chairperson’s statement will not alienate the party’s supporters in Punjab as “we are gaining our position in Punjab.”
Bilawal has done wonders for the PPP in Punjab.
Budget will break the federation, says Bilawal - Pakistan - DAWN.COM

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

He has a point.

PMLN has never been and will never be the party of Federation. They technically don't need to do anything at all for any other province to rule Pakistan again and again. You can choke the life out of Karachi, Sindh, KPK, Balochistan and Kashmir, and guess what, Maryam Nawaz/Hamza Sharif will still win with 'heavy majority' to rule Pakistan like a Queen simply on the basis of Punjabi votes.

The electoral system of Pakistan is tragically Punjab centric, and this is the single biggest threat to democracy and unity of Pakistan

To PPP's credit - they are the ones who passed the 18th Amendment.

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

Bilawal is not my favorite, but he is telling the truth. Why this truth burns you? Pakistan comprises of Sindh, Baluchistan, NWFP also. Why ignore these provinces while making federal budget? You guys get most money from these provinces but in return you gave them misery and chaos.

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

One of those wonders is subject of this thread, are there more like these?

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

How these provinces are ignored please shed some light on it!!! And iam talking about this budget only

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

Recently, PM announced airports for every nook and corner of KPK to please his friend Moulana Fazlu and hide his corruption.

Mind telling me if the budget for KPK airports is in the budget or Nawaz Sharif was blatantly lying as usual?

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

Ohh dear ! Takht e Lahore & Lahoris are two different things .
likely Thugs of Gujarat Chauhdri family is always a power of Takht e Lahore

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

Chaudharies of Gujrat are side villians at best...they never were influential they never will be...they are political crowd thats about it...iam talking about influential political figures...please name them...

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

They will come up with more as they need sindh card now.
26 acre bilawal house in bahria town is also doing wonders for PPP-punjab, with the help of dozens of servants.

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

After 18th amendment, why is it a tragedy for you? You cannot win in punjab?
The fact is parties from the other provinces are not even willing to gather under one platform. Some hate each other to an extreme level.

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

18th Amendment hasn't changed the electoral system or has it? The fact that villages of Punjab decide the fate of whole of Pakistan is indeed a tragedy.

The combined NA seats of all other provinces doesn't add up to NA seats of Punjab - you don't find anything wrong with such imbalance? Be honest!

I'll see how democracy survives a single month in India when the results of only one particular state forms the 'heavy majority' government.

Re: PPP says budget is Punjabistan Centric

What do you mean by fate of whole Pakistan? What is the use of 18th amendment then?
What changes to electoral system do you propose to stop punjab getting federal power?
Lets say punjab is divided and PMLn win from both central punjab and bahawalpur then you will say two provinces are deciding fate of whole Pakistan. This is democracy learn to deal with it.