Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

We should’ve done this like 10 years ago.

http://www.dawn.com/2011/06/23/plan-to-fence-mine-afghan-border.html

Plan to fence, mine Afghan border
By Imran Ali Teepu | From the Newspaper
(4 hours ago) Today

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan is seriously considering to ‘fence and mine’ some important parts of the Pak-Afghan border, in the wake of increasing incursions by militants from the Afghan side into Bajaur, Upper Dir and Mohmand tribal regions, knowledgeable sources told Dawn.

The plan has been there for some time and specific details were also worked out by the security establishment, but it was put on hold because of opposition from Kabul. However, recent incursions from across the Durand Line have made the authorities to consider reviving the project.

Heavily armed militants have crossed into Pakistan’s border more than four times in less than 25 days and clashed with Pakistan’s border forces.

In a recent attack by militants in Mohmand this month, the Pakistan Air Force had to be called in to recapture a post.

The clash led to the death of 25 militants while several Frontier Corps soldiers were injured.The military is concerned over the increasing infiltration.

“The insurgency from across the border is growing and we have already taken up the matter with Afghan officials but there appears to be no end to the incursions. A plan to fence the border is being discussed and a final decision will be taken by senior military officials,” an official told this correspondent.

The fencing and mining, he said, would be carried out at areas of strategic military importance. This, however, will not be the first time that such an exercise will be carried out. After 9/11, Pakistan did fence and mine parts of the 2,500km border after it was accused of failing to stop the Taliban and Al Qaeda militants from crossing over and taking refuge inside Pakistan. The official said the Afghanistan government had always been against fencing the border.

“Pashtuns living on the both sides still can easily cross the border after clearing a few security checks,” the official said.

Maj-Gen Athar Abbas, the spokesman for the army, told Dawn: “We did fence around 35km of the border area as it faced continuous militant incursions. It was a joint project of Isaf and Afghanistan. But then they backed out. It was a very costly project.”

When asked if fencing and mining of four strips along the border was being considered, he said: “Not to my knowledge.”

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

Agreed we should have done that long long ago, anyways dair aayad darust aayad

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

Afghani's will never let us do that. Because this step will make durrand line permanent, which is kind a anesthesia for Afghan nationalists.

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

This will never happen because Afghans will make lot of trouble and will also not let Pakistan do this

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

fence it, mine it, tell everyone that only place they can cross is at checkpoints.
only smugglers, terrorists and ignorant fools will put themselves in harms way then.

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

People of Tribal areas also don't support these acts

Acts of what? Fencing or illegal border crossing?

Question is, should the movement of people/goods between borders of 2 countries be monitored? If the answer is yes then whether someone likes it or not they have to abide by it.

I frikkin dont like the speed limit and will oppose it, but if I speed and get a ticket, I may not like that either but I have to accept the consequence of my actions.

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

Fencing because people of Tribal Areas came with Pakistan on their terms and this is against those terms which Quaid agreed with them and if you will force it than it will create more trouble

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

seal it in any mean asap.

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

Sealing is not a big issue issue is the reaction of the tribals

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

Agreement with Quaid also said that protection of the people of tribal areas is responsibility of GoP, now, sometime terrorists cross this border or sometime afghan to kill and abduct people, the whole border cannot be guarded, whoever want to cross the border, then he may can do it from the check points, even in the euro-zone you don't cross the border where ever you like...get to senses, if border is mined and barbed, then these terrorists can be handled better and as far as i know, people of Chaman may love the idea.

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

so tribals are ok, when terrorist cross boder and attack Pakistan, when Afghan group cross border and attack Pakistan, but they are not happy with the fact that GoP take action to stop such acts??? and to honest the border should have sealed 10 years ago, had we done it back then, we might have not been in the mess we are in...

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

I wish we could seal it..

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

Sir Tribals are not okay with the fencing

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

Why not ?

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

Do they support groups of 50-100 insurgents coming over from the Afghan side and killing them? A lot has changed during the past 10 years.

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

Due to Durrand line, which is an artificial line made by the British which is separating families from each other, like half village is in Pakistan and half in Afghanistan! But due to terrorism and stuff, I think the tribals shouldn't have any objection if people come to the other side legally. Without mining and fencing, forget it we will keep on fighting the war, as the terrorists will keep moving across the border.

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

I guess that is not the real reason , the real reason would be that it will hurt free flow of opium, heroin , arms which provides lively hood and big money to lot of folks in that area. So , have I heard , correct me if I am wrong and misguided.

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

I think the most important thing is security, no opium and smuggling can buy that! otherwise do your research yourself, same families are present on both sides of the border.

Re: Plan to fence, mine Afghan border

for sake of few faimilies we cant allowed a free border from where any natho khaera can get in our land. wish if we could make a wall like china around that border, this border more dangeous then indian one.