Performance of Punjab Government

Time and again I have been opening threads regarding the performance of the national government, lets see the performance of the Punjab government (the government in waiting).

  1. Sasti roti scheme, a complete failure which threw billions of ruppes of the taxpayers down the tandoors…

  2. Kalma Chowk underpass, which was baing made has been put on hold on 19th of August (wastage of further billions of rupees) although five days back Shahbaz Sharif was announcing another under pass after the kalma chowk one… Kalma Chowk underpass-put on hold

  3. The doctors strike which persisted for about 45 days, and the Punjab government showed indifference to it, resulting in deaths of scores of people

  4. The situation of medicines in Punjab hospitals, Ban on purchase by Punjab government Hospitals without vital medicines

  5. Last and not least, lets see what happens with the yellow cab scheme (already proven to be a failure in the previous PMLN government). Jang Economic Session ‘New Yellow Cab Scheme can also be a failure’

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

It was a political stunt, a flopped one and yes no govt should be doing this kind of blunders…

Only if you red what is written in the link you have posted you may not have posted this one, here what they have to say:

It is copied from the same link

Doctor’s strike was the inhuman thing i have ever seen, where even have died because doctors were on strike and was not ready to take care of them… anyway, Doctors/health issue was under federal control prior to the 18th Amendment, there is little what any provincial govt can do about it and by the time strike was going on, 18th amendment was there but the Ministry was not transferred to the Province… for some procedural or technical reason federal govt transferred this and other ministries to the provinces after budget 2011.. i don’t know yet that if the transfer is complete, i however did read in the newspaper that that SS wrote reminder letter to the PM to complete the transfer.
Anyway the strike was not only in Punjab, it was in Sindh and Balochistan as well… you google the links for that

But i would say that being in the career doctors should not come to the point where they refuse to see/treat a patient and let him die.. doctors demand (i guess) have been met but those who died because doctors didn’t treat won’t come back

I guess it was more with the price-hike of the essential medicines… but i don’t know the details of it and what i knew is if govt have agreed to the higher rates then the prices of the medicines available would have sky-rocketed… but as i said, i don’t know the details

Another blunder, or should i say mean to earn cheap publicity, they could have provided the people with easy loans for the value of these cabs… it would have been better but, as i said, blunder is blunder…

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

Not a good performance...........the focus was on running the province like a Union Council Councillor runs his area...........limited to 'naali making' and chhaapay and publicity stunts.......
Shahbz shareef doesn't have any vision on how to setup systems and structures.........

BUT.......he did do some good things....as far as lahore is considered.......finished some road projects etc

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

Compare to rest of provinces, Punjab Government is doing better.

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

I agree, bcoz all other provinces probably think that nothing is better than nonsense.

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

Its mentioned in the same article that the experts of LMTS had asked Shahbaz Sharif to put the project on hold, but he went ahead with wasting public exchequer as usual. After wasting the money he has put the project on hold now.

We should consider the doctors as humans as well, after studying hard for so many years and working ridiculous hours they were being paid less than even constables in Punjab Police. The doctors were asking the government to revise their salaries for the past three years, but every time the government would make committees and subcommittees and hollow promises for in creasing their salaries. Even the previous strike started from token strikes, nothing happened, then they started the full strike still nolthing happened. It was like there was no government at all, anyways in the end the same Punjab Government increased their salaries and I remember Shahbaz Sharif exclaiming in the end that he was being misled by the Health Secretary!

I remember Shabaz Sharif starting a bus company as well, Punjab government based company, I wonder what has happened to that project.

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

I dont like Musharraf, but if development is the criteria for good governance than during Musharraf's rule the development was much more and spread out through the country including Lahore.

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

People used to consider PPP to be a socialist party, but with the introduction of schemes like "Sasti Roti" PMLN is striving to take up this mentle. They still have not learned the lessons. PPP destroyed Pakistan with its socialist policies and PMLN continues to work on the same line.
It is not schemes like Peeli Taxi and Sasti Roti which improve economic conditions of people. Rather it is the creation of jobs. And I don't see any emphasis from government in this regard. Whether it is PMLN provincial government or PPP federal government.

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

or MQM or ANP..:)

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

The Kalma Chowk Flyover is Awesome :jhanda:

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

No idea about that govt. bus service but i do know there are bus companies who have been operating under Privat Public Partner in Lahore and Rawalpindi, these bus services have actually done a good job...

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

I am talking about Lahore transport company, there were a lot of news about it a few months back and some buses were bought from china as well. Anyways now we have ashiana, danish school project and the yellow cab, all of these projects are more politically motivated otherwise no effort has been made what so ever to improve the infrastructure of the province. The problem with sharif's Is that they are very Lahore centric and even in Lahore the potholes on roads have increased in their governance, whereas under Musharraf development was being carried out throughout Punjab. The failed projects of shahbaz sharif has wasted the money that could have been used for public infrastructure and damaged the balance of payment of the province.

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

very good, no one else is present in PMLN to lead the party other than the sharif clan

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

Nothing new for Pakistanis whr all so called democratic parties are dictators in their very roots, be it Bhutto Zardari clan or Sharif clan.

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

Its interesting the Sharif brothers are fighting out in Punjab, like the moghul emperors (son against father, and brother against brother)http://tribune.com.pk/story/237483/hamza-likely-to-head-pml-n-punjab/

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

http://www.dawn.com/2011/08/24/hospitals-await-money-from-zakat-fund.html
**
Hospitals await money from Zakat fund By Aamir Yasin | From the Newspaper (13 hours ago) Today**

RAWALPINDI, Aug 23:** The three government hospitals in Rawalpindi have not got any money from the Zakat fund of the provincial government at the start of this fiscal year.

Sources told Dawn that the Holy Family, Benazir Bhutto and District Headquarters (DHQ) hospitals receive Zakat funds from the provincial government annually in July.

Every year at the start of financial year the provincial government annually provided Rs5 million to DHQ hospital, Rs8 million to Benazir Bhutto Hospital (BBH) and Rs10 million to Holy Family Hospital (HFH) from the Zakat fund.

But sources said this year the provincial government did not transfer funds in the hospitals’ accounts.

The hospitals’ administrations have informed Rawalpindi Medical College (RMC) Principal Dr Afzal Farooqi and the provincial government about how the lack of Zakat funds was affecting treatment of poor patients. The hospitals provide expensive medicines to poor patients after they fill a Zakat form which is approved by the medical superintendent.
**
An epileptic Mahmud Ahmed, 28, said he visited DHQ hospital on Saturday but didn’t get medicine. Doctors say patients with epilepsy depend on expensive medicines like carbamazepine, topiramate and sodium valproate that the hospitals provide to poor patients on Zakat Form.

**Young Doctors Association Rawalpindi President Dr Umer Saeed, who is also working with BBH, told Dawn that 25 heart and 50 diabetic patients visited the hospital but failed to get medicines due to unavailability of Zakat funds.

DHQ Hospital Medical Superintendent Dr Sher Ali Khan Niazi said the hospital has not received Zakat Fund for the fiscal year 2011-12. “We have written letters to provincial government for the release of funds for the benefit of poor patients.” He hoped that the funds would be released soon.**

He said the hospital administration engaged some philanthropists to help patients get medicines, especially those suffering from kidney ailments.

BBH Medical Superintendent Dr Zaman Khan Niazi also confirmed the hospital did not receive Zakat funds. “We did write to social welfare department for the release of funds a month ago but haven’t received any response.”

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

http://www.dawn.com/2011/08/26/lahore-in-free-fall.html

Lahore in free fall?
Murtaza Razvi

His father died for a value system he held dear, and which negated all bigotry and religious extremism. Shahbaz Taseer is now punished for being his father’s son. **Are they going to leverage his release with the Taseers being pressured into accepting blood money and let Salmaan Taseer’s killer walk free? Anything is possible in Shahbaz Sharif’s Punjab, with the Sharifs presiding over a cabinet of ministers, some of whom are hand in glove with the banned militant outfits. The Punjab government’s soft-peddling on rising acts of extremist terrorism is little secret. Shahbazpura it is.

The abduction at gunpoint of Shahbaz Taseer from near his Gulberg home in Lahore is a sorry reminder that Pakistan’s second city is no more the safest place to be. This is the second high-profile kidnapping this month after the American development worker, Warren Weinstein, was taken away from his home in Model Town. Now those aren’t the neighbourhoods with a high crime rate, so these are obviously no ordinary crimes. They have all the extremist symbolism attached to them.**

And hear this: while Lahore falls apart, the Punjab chief minister tours Sindh to sympathise with the flood victims in Badin and victims of the May 12, 2007 killings in Karachi, offering his sterling advice on how to tackle the law and order situation in this troubled metropolis from the safe environs of a five-star hotel. Why isn’t there a voice in the media saying that this Shahbaz (Sharif) is not up to his job, when there’s a chorus against the failure of the Karachi and Sindh administrations in the same quarters? While Kasur drowns in floodwaters, Mr Sharif feels pain and anguish for the flood-affected of Badin. As Punjab goes under the yoke of Talibanisation, with a series of terrorist attacks and kidnappings rocking the province, the Punjab CM’s heart bleeds for targeted killings in Karachi. Someone please help find the logic.

A terrible wave of extremism grips Punjab, while the police do little besides moral-policing citizens. Can someone ask the Punjab government that with such a terrible wave of extremism raging there, how many militants has the police nabbed so far? How many have been brought to justice? Is there really a figure to be quoted? Nay, the government’s priorities lie elsewhere. The Lahore police chief even thwarted the attempt at nabbing the kidnappers of Warren Weinstein by blowing the whistle at the wrong time. This is precisely why the Americans had to go it alone to kill bin Laden. Our law enforcers are not only inept, they have their strings attached to the fingers of more inept people in the administration.

Because nothing is done in Lahore without the CM being behind it, it is obvious that the cops sniffing people’s breath on the streets of Lahore have such explicit orders. Never mind the firearms that one may be carrying, and which may be used for terrorising the people, staging terrorist attacks on shrines or kidnappings, Lahore law enforcers only ensure that you don’t fly a kite by day or consume alcohol by night. And you are free to kill any number of Ahmadis even as they pray to the same Allah as you do. Can’t always find an Ahmadi? Well, there’s always a Shahbaz Bhatti somewhere in a Christian ghetto or a Salman Taseer who would stand up for him, so you are free to have a go at them instead. Welcome to Lahore, 2011.

The self-righteous cries for saving Karachi from the terror of political parties’ armed wings emanating from Lahore by such eminent people as Imran Khan, Shahbaz Sharif and Aitzaz Ahsan, for instance, are ill-timed, to say the least. Why don’t they do something about fixing Lahore, which for all practical purposes is becoming free-for-all. And all this in the name of Allah, which is a real shame.

The abduction of Warren Weinstein and Shahbaz Taseer are but indications of the severity of the threat posed to Punjab by rising extremism. Will Imran Khan, even if only with his supporters at Lums, stage a dharna at Lahore’s Charing Cross against this evil? Some fat chance, well… in Shahbazpura!

— Murtaza Razvi is a member of the staff at Dawn Newspaper.

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

http://www.dawn.com/2011/09/09/all-power-to-the-khadim-i-aala.html

All power to the Khadim-i-Aalaby Murtaza Razvi on September 9th, 2011

**The Khadim-i-Aala, Punjab’s yellow cab scheme is amazing. It is amazing because it will provide self-employment to thousands of people who will win the right to own a cab which is being leased out at very easy installments in a transparent manner by holding a lucky draw of sorts. But the pity is that very few people in the province are aware of the scheme, and perhaps the government is not seeing the kind of run on the banks to apply for the scheme that it expected **— ostensibly because no free Umrah tickets are offered to the winners as an incentive. How very odd. Perhaps that’s why the scheme needs to be heavily advertised at public expense in major newspapers and on TV alike. Creating awareness about the scheme is obviously more important than investing the money being spent on advertisement into a few hundred more yellow cabs.

See, the people have the right to know what their Khadim (servant) is doing for them; because unlike in the Kingdom of Islam presided over by another royal Khadim, of whom our Khadim had been a privileged guest during the traitor Musharraf’s undemocratic and obscenity-filled era when girls danced to blaring, vulgar Indian songs on Lahore’s rooftops as they celebrated Basant, ours is a democracy where even such khadims are answerable to their masters, i.e. the public. What a contrast, really, hence the knockout advertisement campaign.

**You are a fortunate person today to be visiting or living in Lahore. Here you can see for yourself the working of a government that responds to the people’s needs. Because we live in times that favour no one, it is important that you be stopped for inspection by the police as you drive through the city — as often as the threat level on a given day merits. The presence in the city, of course, of outlaws that are obviously not local, is the reason why there are so many police pickets in Lahore every few blocks. However, cell phone snatchers, the armed dacoits and ruffians terrorising the citizens of the city come dressed in camouflage. Sporting urban attire on the criminals’ part is only an indication of how fast Punjab is urbanising and progressing. Unfortunately, with this also comes crime, as it does in Chicago and New York, for instance, it can well be argued.

Lahore is the safest city to be in Pakistan today, that is, if you have a connection in the right quarters. For instance, if you know Hamza Shahbaz Sharif, you can be treated well in a government hospital if you have Dengue fever. Bureaucrats reportedly denied admission to the Services Hospital, Lahore, for treatment are obviously jealous of
Punjab government’s exemplary initiative to combat the Dengue epidemic. The Khadim-i-Aala’s government has taken the right step by allowing the Lahore city district government to sell the chemical liquid to citizens to spray it in their respective areas even though the labels on the bottles of the spray state clearly that it is for government use only and not for sale to the general public. Very pragmatic and transparent indeed.

The Khadim-i-Aala is very fond of threatening the bureaucrats of hanging them upside down if an irregularity is reported about their conduct and the way they handled a given situation. That he does not promise himself a similar punishment says a lot about his sense of responsibility. There’s a catch here. He alone is the last recourse for setting all the wrongs right in Pakistan’s largest province. He indeed is irreplaceable; therefore sanity demands that he be the arbiter of all things and decisions fair.

The facts that people may be dying of dengue fever in Lahore, and others may be drowning in the floodwaters of Sutlej River, fade in the face of the challenges that Sindh’s flood affected people are confronted with, especially in the face of the apathy shown to them by that province’s administration. How the Khadim-i-Aala, Punjab, wishes that his Sindhi counterpart followed his glorious example. And that is, that, in his own words, he will “hang upside down” the officials he finds responsible for adding to people’s misery.

Because the Khadim-i-Aala, Punjab, means everything he says, and shows it through his actions, it is expected that Punjab police will now stop harassing motorists, the commercial theatre workers and ordinary citizens going there, and set out on the trail of real criminals, nab them and get them prosecuted through the very efficient
justice system that we have in the post-Musharraf Punjab.**

All power to the good intensions of the Khadim-i-Aala, Punjab. How one wishes his conduct shames his counterparts in the other provinces into following in his footsteps and doing the right thing by their respective people.

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

http://www.dawn.com/2011/11/01/how-shahbaz-sharif-lost-his-mojo.html
How Shahbaz Sharif lost his mojoby Irfan Waheed on November 1st, 2011

**In October 2008 at an event marking General Musharraf’s 1999 coup, Shahbaz Sharif was addressing a gathering of his supporters. PML-N had just capped a phenomenally successful year which saw them go from the wilderness of exile to the corridors of power. They had ousted their arch-nemesis Musharraf and there was an air of redemption to the rally.
**
**As Shahbaz Sharif wrapped up his speech he broke into verse and began eloquently reciting Habib Jalib’s Dastoor (popularly known as Main Nahee Manta) from memory; the crowd went berserk. With every verse, the crowd numbering only a few hundred worked itself into a frenzy. It was as if the poem had been written for this day. Watching on my computer screen thousands of miles away, I was moved.
**
**On Friday, we witnessed an encore performance. In front of a much larger crowd gathered for the PML-N rally in Lahore, Sharif again broke into verse. In an attempt to breathe life into a dull, diatribe-laced speech he fell back on to a trick that hard worked for him previously. It was a more melodious rendition of the poem but it failed to get the desired response. As he recited “Wo jo saye main har maslihat kay palay”, the irony was inescapable. It was as if he was rebelling against himself. It was a desperate attempt to sell himself as a revolutionary, but no one was buying it. Three years of alignment with the status quo had taken its toll. Shahbaz Sharif had lost his mojo, sacrificed at the altar of expediency.
**
**Shahbaz Sharif and PML-N’s transformation from champions of change to symbols of the status quo did not happen overnight. It began perhaps as far back as late 2007 when PML-N broke ranks with the APDM and decided to contest the general elections held in 2008. Amidst the election fever and the pining for change in the Pakistani public, PML-N got a pass from the public for betraying the APDM. The electorate collectively shrugged as APDM sans PML-N sat out the election. PML-N ended up bagging the votes of all parties that were part of APDM.
**
**Once in power in Punjab, it continued a half-hearted struggle for the restoration of the judiciary. Only when the PML-N government in Punjab was removed in February 2009 did the Sharif brothers throw caution to the wind and begin an all-out, no-holds-barred struggle to restore the judiciary. Had the PCO judiciary not taken that drastic step, the judiciary may never have been restored.
**
**When the Supreme Court declared the NRO unconstitutional, PML-N’s response befuddled many. The credibility of the 2008 elections had been called into question and fresh elections should have been the next logical step. But when PML-N refused to call for fresh elections, it lost the last shreds of its credibility.
**
**If there were any doubts that PML-N had become a pillar of the status quo, the 18th Amendment removed them. By handing ‘party heads’ the authority to declare dissenters as ‘defectors’ and initiate proceedings to unseat a sitting parliamentarian, the 18th Amendment effectively recognised the major political parties as personal fiefdoms. By bringing judicial appointments under a parliamentary commission, the independence of judiciary was curtailed. These two clauses of the 18th Amendment are the clearest evidence of the confluence of interests of the two major political parties. Had the media not been as strong as it has become, it surely would have been gagged in the 18th Amendment as well.
**
**PML-N had vociferously campaigned to reverse Musharraf’s anti-terror policies. Yet they remained silent as the government dragged its feet on implementing the unanimous parliamentary resolution advocating dialogue to resolve terrorism. It watched from the sidelines as Pakistan descended into blood-curdling chaos. If negligence and inaction were declared crimes, PML-N would be the biggest offender. At a critical juncture in Pakistan’s history, PML-N was in a position to arrest the slide into anarchy. Yet they chose not to.
**
**With elections approaching fast, Shahbaz Sharif has made a desperate attempt to arrest his party’s slide. Unfortunately for him, his and his party’s transformation from champions of change to symbols of the status quo has happened in plain sight. It has cost him his Mojo and come election time, seems like it will cost him his government too.

***Irfan Waheed is an engineer working in Austin, Texas. He can be reached at [email protected] or on twitter. *

Re: Performance of Punjab Government

Believe it or not, perfomance of Punjab Government is much better than the other three governments. PML(N) is set to win again in Punjab.