You are absolutely wrong.
1: Calling someone Jahannumi is not takfeer neither it is taking work of Allah in own hand.
2: You are right that **one cannot sanction final destination to any person, as that only Allah can do.
**
3: You are wrong about calling someone Jahannumi … as one can say that certain acts are acts of Jahannumi, and that anyone guilty of such acts are Jahannumi who will burn in hell forever.
For instance, one can say that:
A: Shirk is an act of Jahannumi, Mushriks are jahannumi … and that persons who do Shirk would burn in hell forever.
B: Zulum is an act of Jahannumi, Zalims are Jahannumi … and that persons who do Zulum would burn in hell forever.
C: Takfeer is an act of Jahannumi, Takfeeris are Jahannumi … and that persons who do Takfeer would burn in hell forever.
And so on … and in same way … one can say that:
D: Corruption is an act of Jahannumi, Corrupts are Jahannumi … and that persons who do corruption would burn in hell forever.
If you read my post, you will see that I did not specifically named a single person but only wrote that corruption is act of Jahannumi, corrupts are Jahannumi, and that all who do corruption or have done corruption are going to burn in hell forever. … thus there is nothing wrong in my statement.
If you find that I said anything different than show me and I would repent, but if you could not find that, then I believe, you should apologise, else you would be answerable to me on judgment day for making baseless accusation on me.
[Note: If I would not name any particular person as dosakhee than it would be because I do not know with certainty that the person is really corrupt or it is just perception. Anyhow, if a person is really corrupt then there is little doubt of him being dosakhee, as his sin is not against ‘right of Allah’ that Allah being most merciful may forgive him, but his sin and guilt is against people like you and me, and obviously 180 million Pakistanis (each one of them) could not forgive corrupts, so dozakh for corrupts is certain (and that certainty is nothing to do with taking decision for Allah as the decision on judgement day for corrupts going to dozakh would be of 180 million people he harmed, deceived, and brought misery to]
Your referring to other thread:
I advocated that government should fight and kill who are Khwarijees, rather keep making unending negotiation with them. I still stand on that view.
Actually, in the thread you mentioned, you showed complete ignorance about Khwarijees. I ignored your post because I felt that you are incapable of understanding or you are just pretending that you do not understand. Your ignorance was obvious when you wrote in your post that:
http://www.paklinks.com/gs/pakistan-affairs/600370-twin-blasts-rock-karachi-14.html#post9478802
Reading above post, I gave up. Though:
In above statement, you are not only showing ignorance but most disturbing is that, when you wanted to talk about Khwarijees, at least you could have done some reading and research, but you did not even bothered to do that, rather wrote probably without reading anything.
Fact different to what you wrote is that:
Khwarijees [the one that rose during Ali (RA) time] was entirely a religious movement, rather religious cult. They had no political ambition, political agenda or political interest.
They did believe in head of state philosophy.
They did believe that ‘rule is of Allah alone’, but did not believe that ‘Only Allah is ruler’ in literal sense, as it is obvious Allah would not come to earth to rule. What they believed is that ruler (representative of Allah on earth) should only rule according to book of Allah (Quran), what all Muslims believe, but the difference between them and Muslims is in interpretation of Quran.
They, rather all Muslims believe that Quraish in any respect are not superior or inferior to Muslims, rather superiority of a person depends on his Ilm, Iman, Amaal, Taqwa, and so on.
Actually, Kharijees themselves were all Arabs from Arabian peninsula though mostly from Najd. But then, it is possible that some might be from Hijaz and Yemen … and it is possible that some amongst them might be Quraish.
Some people think that since Kufa and Basra is in Iraq, people in Kufa and Basra must be Iraqis, but that is not true. Kufa and Basra were garrison cities established during time of Umar (RA) when Muslims were fighting Persian, and thus inhabitants of Kufa and Basra are mostly Muslim Arabs and their descendants from Arabian peninsula.
Khwarijees did fight along with Ali (RA) in battle of Siffin. At that time, they were considered Muslims and part of Ali (RA) army.
They were upset about arbitration that followed battle siffin. Actually, when facing defeat, Ameer Muawiya raised Quran and asked for arbitration. A group (later to become Khwarijs) in Ali (RA) army, seeing Quran raised, started persuading Ali (RA) to agree for arbitration, but got discontent after realising the deception from Ameer Muawiya under the cover of arbitration, started saying that arbitration was sinful act, started ‘repenting to Allah’ on their initial agreement and persuasion for arbitration, and started asking Ali (RA) to repent too, but when Ali (RA) did not agreed on their interpretation that arbitration was sinful act, and did not agree that he should repent, they left Ali (RA) armed forces.
It was these people who after leaving army of Ali (RA), started doing Takfeer according to their understanding of Islam (and Quran), and started persecuting and killing Muslims because of their ‘takfeer and understanding of Islam’ (what Pakistani Khwarijees are doing today). Ali (RA) went after them to safeguard Muslims from their ‘fitna’. Ali (RA) tried to talk with this group, and most in the group repented and joined Ali (RA) again. Though some who stayed adamant fought Ali (RA) at Naharwan and were mostly killed.
[Note: These people are not called Kharijees because they left Ali (RA) army, neither Ali (RA) fought them because they rebelled, or showed aggression against Ali (RA) or attacked Ali (RA) rule.
Ali (RA) fought them because they started creating fitna with their takfeer, persecution and killing Muslims.]
